Changes in Academic Performance and Learning Approach During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Three-Year Comparative Study in Diverse Learning Environments

Hannah X. Glowacki¹, Teresa Siby¹, Kelsey Van¹, David M. Beauchamp¹, Elaina B.K. Brendel¹, Linda Kim¹, Jessie L. Burns¹ and Jennifer M. Monk^1,

¹Department of Human Health and Nutritional Science, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario, Canada

Cite this paper:
Hannah X. Glowacki, Teresa Siby, Kelsey Van, David M. Beauchamp, Elaina B.K. Brendel, Linda Kim, Jessie L. Burns and Jennifer M. Monk. Changes in Academic Performance and Learning Approach During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Three-Year Comparative Study in Diverse Learning Environments. American Journal of Educational Research. 2025; 13(2):92-101. doi: 10.12691/education-13-2-8

Abstract

During the COVID-19 pandemic, courses traditionally taught in-person were adapted to an online learning environment, and following the removal of physical distancing restrictions, courses were subsequently transitioned back into a traditional in-person learning environment. During this period of time, concerns were raised regarding student stress levels, engagement, academic performance, and the overall quality of the educational experience provided during pandemic-associated online learning. In this three-year comparative study, we used online surveys to compare three distinct learning environments within the context of the same fourth-year biological science course across three separate years: i) online (winter 2021; n=263), ii) hybrid (combined online and in-person lectures, winter 2022; n=210), and iii) in-person (winter 2023; n=171). The results indicate that there was no difference between learning environments in students’ final grades, perceived stress levels, and learning approach (deep and surface) scores (P>0.05), suggesting that students were adapting to different learning environments and academic outcomes. These results were consistent during the COVID-19 pandemic and in the years transitioning out of COVID-19-associated restrictions. However, in comparison to in-person learning, students associated the online learning environment with more overall stress, specifically stress associated with organizing a schedule and a higher workload (P<0.05). Collectively, these findings demonstrate that a consistent educational experience can be provided in online learning without adverse effects on students’ grades, overall perceived stress levels, and learning approach, which should be considered when making decisions regarding the effectiveness of online learning or the continuation of course delivery within an online environment post-pandemic.

Keywords:
online learning hybrid learning in-person learning COVID-19 academic stress learning approach academic performance

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References:

[1]	Fogg, B.J, Persuasive technology: using computers to change what we think and do, Morgan Kaufmann Publishers, Boston, 2003, 30-35.
[2]	Hirsh, H., Coen, M.H., Mozer, M.C., Hasha, R. and Flanagan, J.L, “Room service, AI-style,” IEEE intelligent systems, 14 (2). 8-19. Jul. 2002.
[3]	T. Eckes, The Developmental Social Psychology of Gender, Lawrence Erlbaum, 2000. [E-book] Available: netLibrary e-book.
[4]	Ali, W., “Online and Remote Learning in Higher Education Institutes: A Necessity in Light of COVID-19 Pandemic,” HES, 10 (3). May. 2020.
[5]	Alqurashi, E., “Predicting Student Satisfaction and Perceived Learning within Online Learning Environments,” Distance Education, 40 (1). 133-148. Jan. 2019.
[6]	Dhawan, S., “Online Learning: A Panacea in the Time of COVID-19 Crisi”. Journal of Educational Technology Systems, 49 (1). 5-22. Sept. 2020.
[7]	Banihashem, S.K., Noroozi, O., Den Brok, P., Biemans, H.J.A., and Kerman, N.T., “Modeling Teachers’ and Students’ Attitudes, Emotions, and Perceptions in Blended Education: Towards Post-Pandemic Education,” The International Journal of Management Education. 21 (2). July. 2023.
[8]	Holcomb, L.B., King, F.B., and Brown, S.W., “Student Traits and Attributes Contributing to Success in Online Courses: Evaluation of University Online Courses,” Journal of Interactive Online Learning, 2 (3). 1-17. Dec. 2004.
[9]	Kauffman, H., “A Review of Predictive Factors of Student Success in and Satisfaction with Online Learning,” Research in Learning Technology, 23. Aug. 2015.
[10]	Abdull Mutalib, A.A., Md. Akim, A., and Jaafar, M.H., “A Systematic Review of Health Sciences Students’ Online Learning during the COVID-19 Pandemic,” BMC Med Educ, 22 (524). Aug. 2022.
[11]	Zhao, X., and Xue, W., “From Online to Offline Education in the Post-Pandemic Era: Challenges Encountered by International Students at British Universities,” Front. Psychol, 13. Jan. 2023.
[12]	Aslan, I., Ochnik, D., Çınar, O., “Exploring Perceived Stress among Students in Turkey during the COVID-19 Pandemic,” IJERPH, 17 (23). Dec. 2020.
[13]	Biber, D.D., Melton, B., and Czech, D.R., “The Impact of COVID-19 on College Anxiety, Optimism, Gratitude, and Course Satisfaction,” Journal of American College Health, 70 (7). 1947-1952. Oct. 2020.
[14]	Fitzgerald, A., and Konrad, S., “Transition in Learning during COVID‐19: Student Nurse Anxiety, Stress, and Resource Support,” Nursing Forum, 56. 298-304. April. 2021.
[15]	Odriozola-González, P., Planchuelo-Gómez, Á., Irurtia, M.J., and De Luis-García, R., “Psychological Effects of the COVID-19 Outbreak and Lockdown among Students and Workers of a Spanish University,” Psychiatry Research, 290. Aug. 2020.
[16]	Pennino, E., Ishikawa, C., Ghosh Hajra, S., Singh, N., and McDonald, K,. “Student Anxiety and Engagement with Online Instruction across Two Semesters of COVID-19 Disruptions,” J Microbiol Biol Educ., 23. April. 2022.
[17]	Rogowska, A.M., Kuśnierz, C., and Bokszczanin, A., “Examining Anxiety, Life Satisfaction, General Health, Stress and Coping Styles During COVID-19 Pandemic in Polish Sample of University Students.” PRBM, 13. 797-811. Sept. 2020.
[18]	Saravanan, C., Mahmoud, I., Elshami, W., and Taha, M.H., “Knowledge, Anxiety, Fear, and Psychological Distress About COVID-19 Among University Students in the United Arab Emirates,” Front. Psychiatry, 11. Oct. 2020.
[19]	Son, C., Hegde, S., Smith, A., Wang, X., and Sasangohar, F., “Effects of COVID-19 on College Students’ Mental Health in the United States: Interview Survey Study,” J Med Internet Res, 22 (9). Sept. 2020.
[20]	Wood, C.I., Yu, Z., Sealy, D.-A., Moss, I., Zigbuo-Wenzler, E., McFadden, C., Landi, D., and Brace, A.M., “Mental Health Impacts of the COVID-19 Pandemic on College Students,” Journal of American College Health, 72 (2). 463-468. March. 2022.
[21]	Beauchamp, D.M., and Monk, J.M., “Effect of Optional Assessments on Student Engagement, Learning Approach, Stress, and Perceptions of Online Learning during COVID-19,” IJHE, 11 (5). May. 2022.
[22]	Clabaugh, A., Duque, J.F., and Fields, L.J., “Academic Stress and Emotional Well-Being in United States College Students Following Onset of the COVID-19 Pandemic,” Front. Psychol., 12. March. 2021.
[23]	Fruehwirth, J.C., Biswas, S., and Perreira, K.M., “The Covid-19 Pandemic and Mental Health of First-Year College Students: Examining the Effect of Covid-19 Stressors Using Longitudinal Data,” PLoS ONE, 16 (3). March. 2021.
[24]	Hamza, C.A., Ewing, L., Heath, N.L., and Goldstein, A.L., “When Social Isolation Is Nothing New: A Longitudinal Study on Psychological Distress during COVID-19 among University Students with and without Preexisting Mental Health Concerns,” Canadian Psychology / Psychologie canadienne, 62. 20-30. Feb. 2021.
[25]	Omar, M.K., Hassan, M., Arsad, N.M., Ismail, N., Jamaluddin, R., and Jusoh, R., “Undergraduates Students’ Learning Experience on the Impact of Online Learning during Pandemic,” JSS, 9 (9). 167-184. 2021.
[26]	Alsoufi, A., Alsuyihili, A., Msherghi, A., Elhadi, A., Atiyah, H., Ashini, A., Ashwieb, A., Ghula, M., Ben Hasan, H., Abudabuos, S., Alameen, H., Abokhdhir, T., Anaiba, M., Nagib, T., Shuwayyah, A., Benothman, R., Arrefae, G., Alkhwayildi, A., Alhadi, A., Zaid, A., Elhadi, M., and Kotozaki, Y., “Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Medical Education: Medical Students’ Knowledge, Attitudes, and Practices Regarding Electronic Learning,” PLoS ONE, 15 (11). Nov. 2020.
[27]	Anwar, A., Mansoor, H., Faisal, D., and Khan, H.S., “E-Learning amid the COVID-19 Lockdown: Standpoint of Medical and Dental Undergraduates,” Pak J Med Sci, 37 (1). Dec. 2020.
[28]	Photopoulos, P., Tsonos, C., Stavrakas, I., and Triantis, D., “Remote and In-Person Learning: Utility Versus Social Experience,” SN COMPUT. SCI., 4 (2). Dec. 2022.
[29]	Ameri, H., Mahami‐Oskouei, M., Sharafi, S., Saadatjoo, S., Miri, M., and Arab‐Zozani, M., “Investigating the Strengths and Weaknesses of Online Education during COVID ‐19 Pandemic from the Perspective of Professors and Students of Medical Universities and Proposing Solutions: A Qualitative Study,” Biochem Molecular Bio Educ, 51 (1). 94-102. Jan. 2023.
[30]	Beauchamp, D.M., Newton, G., and Monk, J.M., “Adapting Literature Critique Engagement Activities for Online Learning Due to COVID-19: Use of Online Learning Groups to Promote Scientific Literacy Capabilities in Undergraduate Nutrition Education,” IJHE, 10 (7). June. 2021.
[31]	Briggs, M.A., Thornton, C., McIver, V.J., Rumbold, P.L.S., and Peart, D.J., “Investigation into the Transition to Online Learning Due to the COVID-19 Pandemic, between New and Continuing Undergraduate Students,” Journal of Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism Education, 32. June. 2023.
[32]	Kumari, S., Gautam, H., Nityadarshini, N., Das, B.K., and Chaudhry, R., “Online Classes versus Traditional Classes? Comparison during COVID-19,” Journal of Education and Health Promotion, 10 (1). Jan. 2021.
[33]	Turan, Z., Kucuk, S., and Cilligol Karabey, S., “The University Students’ Self-Regulated Effort, Flexibility and Satisfaction in Distance Education,” Int J Educ Technol High Educ, 19 (35). Dec. 2022.
[34]	Van, K., Beauchamp, D.M., Rachid, H., Mansour, M., Buckley, B., Choi, D., Prescod, A., and Monk, J.M., “Impact of the COVID-19-Induced Shift to Online Dietetics Training on PDEP Competency Acquisition and Mental Health,” Canadian Journal of Dietetic Practice and Research, 83 (3). 144-146. Sept. 2022.
[35]	Venton, B.J., and Pompano, R.R., “Strategies for Enhancing Remote Student Engagement through Active Learning,” Anal Bioanal Chem, 413 (6). 1507-1512. March. 2021.
[36]	Watson, C., Templet, T., Leigh, G., Broussard, L., and Gillis, L., “Student and Faculty Perceptions of Effectiveness of Online Teaching Modalities,” Nurse Education Today, 120. Jan. 2023.
[37]	Cahapin, E., Santiago, C.J., Malabag, B., Reyes, J., Legaspi, G., and Benedicto, M.J., “Sentiment Analysis of Students’ Perception towards the Implementation of Limited In-Person Learning: A Post-Pandemic Perspective,” IJCSR, 7. 1664-1684. Jan. 2023.
[38]	Cranfield, D.J., Tick, A., Venter, I.M., Blignaut, R.J., and Renaud, K., “Higher Education Students’ Perceptions of Online Learning during COVID-19—A Comparative Study,” Education Sciences, 11 (403). Aug. 2021.
[39]	Zapata-Cuervo, N., Montes-Guerra, M.I., Shin, H.H., Jeong, M., and Cho, M.-H., “Students’ Psychological Perceptions Toward Online Learning Engagement and Outcomes during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Comparative Analysis of Students in Three Different Countries,” Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Education, 35 (2). 108-122. April. 2021.
[40]	Biggs, J., Kember, D., and Leung, D.Y.P., “The Revised Two‐factor Study Process Questionnaire: R‐SPQ‐2F,” Brit J of Edu Psychol, 71 (1). 133-149. Mar. 2001.
[41]	Cohen, S., Kamarck, T., and Mermelstein, R., “A Global Measure of Perceived Stress,” Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 24 (4). Dec. 1983.
[42]	Vautier, A., Enns, K., and Cadaret, C., “Impacts of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Student Performance and Perceptions of Learning,” NACTA J., 67 (1). June. 2023.
[43]	Cavanaugh, J., Jacquemin, S., and Junker, C., “A Look at Student Performance during the COVID-19 Pandemic,” QAE, 31 (1). 33-43. Jan. 2023.
[44]	Doz, D., “Students’ Mathematics Achievements: A Comparison between Pre- and Post-COVID-19 Pandemic,” E&SD, 16 (4). 34-47. Dec. 2021.
[45]	Lupas, K.K., Mavrakis, A., Altszuler, A., Tower, D., Gnagy, E., MacPhee, F., Ramos, M., Merrill, B., Ward, L., Gordon, C., Schatz, N., Fabiano, G., and Pelham, W., “The Short-Term Impact of Remote Instruction on Achievement in Children with ADHD during the COVID-19 Pandemic,” School Psychology, 36 (5). 313-324. Sept. 2021.
[46]	McWatt, S.C., “Responding to Covid‐19: A Thematic Analysis of Students’ Perspectives on Modified Learning Activities during an Emergency Transition to Remote Human Anatomy Education,” Anatomical Sciences Ed, 14 (6). 721-738. Nov. 2021.
[47]	Supriya, K., Mead, C., Anbar, A.D., Caulkins, J.L., Collins, J.P., Cooper, K.M., LePore, P.C., Lewis, T., Pate, A., Scott, R.A., and Brownell, S.E., “Undergraduate Biology Students Received Higher Grades During COVID-19 but Perceived Negative Effects on Learning,” Front. Educ., 6. Oct. 2021.
[48]	Beheshti, M.B., and Jeong, K.Y., “The Impact of COVID-19 pandemic on U.S. students’ academic performance”. 2022.
[49]	Deho, O.B., Liu, L., Joksimovic, S., Li, J., Zhan, C., and Liu, J., “Assessing the Causal Impact of Online Instruction Due to COVID-19 on Students’ Grades and Its Aftermath on Grade Prediction Models,” in GoodIT 2022: ACM International Conference on Information Technology for Social Good, ACM, 32–38.
[50]	Kim, D.-H., Lee, H.J., Lin, Y., and Kang, Y.J., “Changes in Academic Performance in the Online, Integrated System-Based Curriculum Implemented Due to the COVID-19 Pandemic in a Medical School in Korea,” J Educ Eval Health Prof, 18 (24). Sept. 2021.
[51]	Nazempour, R., Darabi, H., and Nelson, P.C., “Impacts on Students’ Academic Performance Due to Emergency Transition to Remote Teaching during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Financial Engineering Course Case Study,” Education Sciences, 12 (202). March. 2022.
[52]	Bauer, F.W., Dunham, S.M., and Husmann, P.R., “Watching or Waiting?: Effects of In‐Person Active Learning Sessions on Student Engagement with Lecture Recordings and Course Resources,” The FASEB Journal, 36. May. 2022.
[53]	Becker, T.B., Fenton, J.I., Nikolai, M., Comstock, S.S., Swada, J.G., Weatherspoon, L.J., and Tucker, R.M., “The Impact of COVID-19 on Student Learning during the Transition from Remote to in-Person Learning: Using Mind Mapping to Identify and Address Faculty Concerns,” Advances in Physiology Education, 46 (4). 742-751. Dec. 2022.
[54]	Kuhfeld, M., Soland, J., Lewis, K., Ruzek, E., and Johnson, A., “The COVID-19 School Year: Learning and Recovery Across 2020-2021,” AERA Open, 8. Jan. 2022.
[55]	Hajedris, N.D.A.O., “Effect of the Sudden Shift to E-Learning during COVID 19 Pandemic on Student Engagement,” Int J Pharm Res. Allied Sci., 10 (4). 57-66. 2021.
[56]	King, S.M., “Approaches to Promoting Student Engagement in Organic Chemistry Before, During, and After the COVID-19 Pandemic: Insights and Reflections,” J. Chem. Educ., 100 (1). 243-250. Jan. 2023.
[57]	Ober, T.M., Cheng, Y., Carter, M.F., and Liu, C., “Disruptiveness of COVID-19: Differences in Course Engagement, Self-Appraisal, and Learning,” AERA Open, 9. Jan. 2023.
[58]	Walker, K.A., Koralesky, K.E., “Student and Instructor Perceptions of Engagement after the Rapid Online Transition of Teaching Due to COVID‐19,” Natural Sciences Education, 50 (1). Jan. 2021.
[59]	Monk, J., Beauchamp, D.M., Holt, R.K.V., and Van, K., “Effectiveness of Literature Critique Peer Discussions to Build Scientific Literacy Skills, Engagement and Improve Learning-Related Emotions during COVID-19-Associated Online Learning,” American Journal of Educational Research, 11 (5). 303-315. May. 2023.
[60]	Adedoyin, O.B., and Soykan, E., “Covid-19 Pandemic and Online Learning: The Challenges and Opportunities,” Interactive Learning Environments, 31 (2). 863-875. Sept. 2020.
[61]	Kahu, E.R., “Framing Student Engagement in Higher Education,” Studies in Higher Education, 38 (5). 758-773. Aug. 2011.
[62]	Robinson, C.C., and Hullinger, H., “New Benchmarks in Higher Education: Student Engagement in Online Learning,” Journal of Education for Business, 84 (2). 101-109. Nov. 2008.
[63]	Song, L., Singleton, E.S., Hill, J.R., and Koh, M.H., “Improving Online Learning: Student Perceptions of Useful and Challenging Characteristics,” The Internet and Higher Education, 7 (1). 59-70. Jan. 2004.
[64]	Wang, C.-H., Shannon, D.M., and Ross, M.E., “Students’ Characteristics, Self-Regulated Learning, Technology Self-Efficacy, and Course Outcomes in Online Learning,” Distance Education, 34 (3). 302-323. Nov. 2013.
[65]	Hu, X., and Yeo, G.B., “Emotional Exhaustion and Reduced Self-Efficacy: The Mediating Role of Deep and Surface Learning Strategies,” Motiv Emot, 44 (5). 785-795. Oct. 2020.
[66]	Teoh, H.C., Abdullah, M.C., Roslan, S., and Mohd Daud, S., “Assessing Students Approaches to Learning Using a Matrix Framework in a Malaysian Public University,” SpringerPlus, 3 (54). Dec. 2014.
[67]	Pacheco-Castillo, J., Casuso-Holgado, M.-J., Labajos-Manzanares, M.-T., and Moreno-Morales, N., “Academic Stress among Nursing Students in a Private University at Puerto Rico, and Its Association with Their Academic Performance,” OJN, 11 (9). 742-756. 2021.
[68]	Aagaard, K., Kladakis, A., and Nielsen, M.W., “Concentration or Dispersal of Research Funding?” Quantitative Science Studies, 1 (1). 117-149. Feb. 2020.
[69]	Kahu, E.R., and Nelson, K., “Student Engagement in the Educational Interface: Understanding the Mechanisms of Student Success,” Higher Education Research & Development, 37 (1). 58-71. Jan. 2018.
[70]	Rossi, R.A., Krouse, A.M., and Klein, J., “Undergraduate Student Stress, Classroom Engagement, and Self-Directed Learning Postcurricular Revision,” J Nurs Educ, 60 (10). 556-569. Oct. 2021.
[71]	Barrows, J., Dunn, S., and A. Lloyd, C., “Anxiety, Self-Efficacy, and College Exam Grades,” Universal Journal of Educational Research, 1 (3). 204-208. Oct. 2013.
[72]	Chapell, M.S., Blanding, Z.B., Silverstein, M.E., Takahashi, M., Newman, B., Gubi, A., and McCann, N., “Test Anxiety and Academic Performance in Undergraduate and Graduate Students,” Journal of Educational Psychology, 97 (2). 268-274. May. 2005.
[73]	England, B.J., Brigati, J.R., and Schussler, E.E., “Student Anxiety in Introductory Biology Classrooms: Perceptions about Active Learning and Persistence in the Major,” PLoS ONE, 12 (8). Aug. 2017.
[74]	Gloria, C.T., and Steinhardt, M.A., “Relationships Among Positive Emotions, Coping, Resilience and Mental Health,” Stress and Health, 32 (2). 145-156. April. 2016.
[75]	Guo, F., Tian, Y., Zhong, F., Wu, C., Cui, Y., and Huang, C., “Intensity of Physical Activity and Depressive Symptoms in College Students: Fitness Improvement Tactics in Youth (FITYou) Project,” PRBM, 13. 787-796. Sept. 2020.
[76]	Hancock, D.R., “Effects of Test Anxiety and Evaluative Threat on Students’ Achievement and Motivation,” The Journal of Educational Research, 94 (5). 284-290. May. 2001.
[77]	Cavanaugh, J., and Jacquemin, S.J., “A Large Sample Comparison of Grade Based Student Learning Outcomes in Online vs. Face-to-Face Courses,” OLJ, 19 (2). Feb. 2015.
[78]	Soffer, T., and Nachmias, R., “Effectiveness of Learning in Online Academic Courses Compared with Face‐to‐face Courses in Higher Education,” Computer Assisted Learning, 34 (5). 534-543. Oct. 2018.
[79]	Siby, T., Burns, J.L., Van, K., Glowacki, H.X., Alzubi, A., Beauchamp, D.M., and Monk, J.M., “Does Students’ Learning Environment Choice (Online, Hybrid, In-Person Options Within the Same Course Offering) Influence Academic Stress and the Learning Experience During the COVID-19 Pandemic?” American Journal of Educational Research, 12 (12). 503-516. Dec. 2024.