Critical Citation and Intertextuality in Academic Writing

Hongqin Zhao¹ and Yaqian Li^2,

¹English Department, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China

²Social and Policy Science Department, Bath University, Bath, UK

Cite this paper:
Hongqin Zhao and Yaqian Li. Critical Citation and Intertextuality in Academic Writing. World Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities. 2025; 11(2):25-32. doi: 10.12691/wjssh-11-2-2

Abstract

Referencing and citation present significant challenges for novice academic writers, particularly for university students writing in English as a foreign or second language (EFL/ESL) across disciplines. This article investigates undergraduate students’ referencing and citation practices through an analysis of their literature review texts, collected over two rounds of assignments from an EFL academic writing course at a Chinese university. The analytical framework adopted assesses both the quantity and contextual use of references, distinguishing between direct and indirect citations, while also examining how students employed references for confirmatory and critical purposes. The findings reveal a general tendency toward minimal use of direct and critical referencing, with few instances where citations were used for critique and comparison. These results suggest a need for writing instruction that promotes a deeper understanding of authentic intertextual citations with scholarly sources. Pedagogy in China and broader EFL/ESL contexts shoulders a responsibility of supporting students’ development in using overt intertextual citations in writing more effectively, by addressing the current imbalance—namely, the overreliance on indirect quotation and the underuse of critical and direct citation practices for scientific intertextuality in academic writing.

Keywords:
Critical Citation Intertextuality Indirect Citation Direct Citation Academic Writing

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References:

[1]	Bordignon, F. (2022). Critical citations in knowledge construction and citation analysis: From paradox to definition. Scientometrics, 127, 959–972.
[2]	Pearson, A. W., & Sharma, P. (2015). Referencing in scholarly articles: What is just right? Family Business Review, 28(3), 188-192.
[3]	Aveyard, H. (2014). Doing a literature review in health and social care: A practical guide (3rded.). Open University Press.
[4]	Chigbu, U. E., Atiku, S. O., & Plessis, C. C. (2021). The science of literature reviews: Searching, identifying, selecting, and synthesizing. Publications, 11(2).
[5]	Kapranov, O. (2023). Citation and referencing practices in argumentative essay writing by upper-intermediate EFL students. Studia AnglicaResoviensia, 20, 71–87.
[6]	Petrić, B. (2012). Legitimate textual borrowing: Direct quotations in L2 student writing. Journal of Second Language Writing, 21, 102–117.
[7]	Mavrogenis, A. F., &Scarlat, M. M. (2021). Writing for “internal orthopaedics”: Referencing quality citations. International Orthopedics, 45, 3011-3014.
[8]	Graff, G., & Birkenstein, C. (2010). They say, I say: The moves that matter in academic writing (2nd ed.). W.W. Norton & Co.
[9]	Pecorari, D. (2013). Teaching to avoid plagiarism: How to promote good source use. Open University Press.
[10]	Wette, R. (Ed.). (2023). Teaching and learning source-based writing: Current perspectives and future directions. Routledge.
[11]	Badenhorst, C. (2018). Citation practices of postgraduate students conducting literature reviews. London Review of Education, 16(1).
[12]	Neville, C. (2007). The complete guide to referencing and avoiding plagiarism (2nd ed.). Open University Press.
[13]	Petrić, B., & Harwood, N. (2023). Tracing changes in the citing practices of a master’s student: A longitudinal case study. In R. Wette (Ed.), Teaching and Learning Source-Based Writing: Current perspectives and future directions (pp.27-47). Routledge.
[14]	Petrić, B., & Castelló, M. (2024). The thesis writing journeys of bachelor’s and master’s students: A transnational European perspective. Multilingual Matters.
[15]	Enk, A., & Power, K. (2017). What is a research article? Genre variability and data selection in genre research. Journal of English for Academic Purposes, 29, 1-11.
[16]	Björk, L., Bräuer, G., Rienecker, L., & Jørgensen, P. (Eds.). (2003). Teaching academic writing in European higher education. Kluwer Academic Publishers.
[17]	Jarkovská, M., &Kučírková. L. (2020). Citation practices in EFL academic writing: The use ofreporting verbs in Master’s thesis literature reviews. Indonesian Journal of Applied Linguistics, 10(2), 571-579. https:// ejournal.upi.edu/ index.php/ IJAL/ article/ view/29033/13056.
[18]	Rezeki, Y. (2018). Analysis of EFL students practices and problems in academic writing. International Journal of Educational Best Practices (IJEBP), 2(1), 62-72.
[19]	Sun, Y. (2008). Citation problems of Chinese MA theses and pedagogical implications. The Journal of Asia TEFL, 5(1), 1-27.
[20]	Wang, Y., &Xie, Q. (2022). Diagnostic assessment of novice EFL learners' discourse competence in academic writing: A case study, Language Testing in Asia, 12(47).
[21]	Zhao, H. Q. (2024). Striking a balance act on topic familiarity and critical thinking ofcurriculum for first-year writing. International Journal of Arts, Humanities & Social Science 5(1), 20-32.
[22]	Docherty, P. (2019). An exploratory study in the use of direct quotation by L2 entry level bachelor students. Journal of English for Academic Purposes, 40, 26-40.
[23]	Byard, R. W. (2021). Academic referencing – a dying art. Forensic Science, Medicine and Pathology,17, 1–2.
[24]	Lyu, D., Ruan, X., Xie, J., & Cheng, Y. (2021). The classification of citing motivations: a meta-synthesis. Scientometrics, 126, 3243-3264.
[25]	Erikson, M. G. & Erlandson, P. (2014). A taxonomy of motives to cite. Social Studies of Science, 44(4), 625-637.
[26]	Lin, C. (2018). An analysis of citation functions in humanities and social sciences research from the perspective of problematic citation analysis assumptions. Scientometrics, 116, 797-813.
[27]	Rabinowitz, H., & Vogel, S. (Eds.). (2009). The manual of scientific style: A guide for authors, editors, and researchers. Elsevier.
[28]	Hood, S. (2010). Appraising research: Evaluating in academic writing. Palgrave Macmillan.
[29]	Pecorari, D. (2010). Academic writing and plagiarism: A linguistic analysis. Bloomsbury Publishing.
[30]	Humphrey, J., & Holmes, J. (2009). Style and ethics in scientific and engineering communication. Morgan & Claypool
[31]	Leu, S., & Neumann, H. (2023). Patchwriting: Co-opting a transgressive practice for pedagogical purposes. In R. Wette (Ed.), Teaching and Learning Source-Based Writing: Current perspectives and future directions (pp. 80-94). Routledge.
[32]	Thompson, P. (2005). Points of focus and position: intertextual reference in PhD theses. Journal of English for Academic Purposes, 4(4), 307–323.
[33]	Plett, H. (Ed.). (1991). Intertextuality, Research in text theory. Walter de Gruyter.
[34]	Verheijen, L. (2015). The language of quoting in academic writing. Dutch Journal of Applied Linguistics, 4 (1), 101–121.
[35]	Kellogg, R. (1994). The psychology of writing. Oxford University Press.
[36]	Tahamtan, I., & Bornmann, L. (2019). What do citation counts measure? An updated review of studies on citations in scientific documents published between 2006 and 2018. Journal of Informetrics, 121(3), 1635-1684.
[37]	Metcalfe, M. (2003). Author (ity): The literature review as expert witnesses. Forum: Qualitative Social Research, 4(1).
[38]	Ridley, D. (2012). The literature review: A step-by-step guide for students (2nd ed). Sage.
[39]	Klavans, R., & Boyack, K. W. (2017). Which type of citation analysis generates the most accurate taxonomy of scientific and technical knowledge?Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 68(4), 984–998.
[40]	Lenoir, T. (1998). Inscribing science: Scientific texts and the materiality of communication. Stanford University Press.
[41]	Pecorari, D., & Shaw, P. (2012). Types of student intertextuality and faculty attitudes. Journal of Second Language Writing, 21(2), 149-164.
[42]	Zhao, H. Q. (2023). A curricular approach to academic writing and scientific discourse. Amazon KDP Pub.