Are Some Very Capable Students Being Denied Their Dream by the Change from a Traditional to an Integrated Curriculum?

Roger J. Bick^1,

¹Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, UT McGovern Medical School, Houston, Texas 77030, USA

Cite this paper:
Roger J. Bick. Are Some Very Capable Students Being Denied Their Dream by the Change from a Traditional to an Integrated Curriculum?. American Journal of Educational Research. 2018; 6(8):1229-1232. doi: 10.12691/education-6-8-23

Abstract

The ‘new’ curriculum for medical students inserts basic sciences into case based scenarios in the early years of study, giving them a rapid introduction to the realities of many things they will face upon encountering patients and entering clinics and hospitals. The curriculum also has a large percentage of small group problem based learning (PBL) and team based learning (TBL) hours, with the idea that students are encouraged to undertake self-study and self-directed learning prior to using gained knowledge in discussions, presented cases and clinical problems. This method fosters self-discipline and leads to better teamwork and discussions among groups, with students intensely investigating studies, data and reports to formulate their input. To this extent, the new curriculum is less regimented, and not a data-in, data-out type of teaching in which a lecture, and maybe a lab, gives the students the topics of need-to-know and lessens the requirement for self-study and self-critiquing, which doesn’t promote investigation, diversity of study methods and the ability to learn from self-taught ideals that are then incorporated into their studies. The idea is for students to be more capable of initiating their own interests and be more self-reliant and able, rather than simply taking a fact from a lecture and rewriting it as an answer on an exam. This UCSF link gives a good synopsis; https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2016/08/403791/ucsf-launches-medical-school-curriculum-21st-century. Overall the revamped curriculum has been a success at many medical schools, usually after a development period of three years or so. Students tend to like it, embrace the changes and appreciate the less rigorous demands together with a pass/fail grading system. However, there are problems, as some students obviously struggle with self-study, and longitudinal grading and assessment. It is obvious that some are much more comfortable with the lecture-lab-exam format and we must entertain the fact that maybe good students and future good doctors are being lost due to their study method preferences.

Keywords:
medical school curriculum self-study self-directed learning USMLE learning outcomes case-based traditional

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References:

[1]	Seidman, K. McGill students voice concerns over new medical school curriculum. Montreal Gazette. http://monteralgazette.com/local-news/mcgill-students-voice-concerns-over-new-medical-school-curriculum. May 3, 2014. [Accessed May 2018].
[2]	Strauss, V., Sirovick, B. A disturbing truth about medical schools – and America’s future doctors. Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2017/05/08/a-disturbing-truth-about-medical-school-and-americas-future-doctors/?utm_term=.f2f34314e457. May 8, 2017. [Accessed May 2018].
[3]	Mancias, P., Bick, R.J. Are students that do not complete their medical school education abandoned? Is more help needed? Open Medical Education Journal, 6: 22-27. 2013.
[4]	Maher, B.M., Hynes, H., Sweeney, C., Khashan, A.S., O’Rourke, M., Doran, K., Harris, A. and O’Flynn, S. Medical school attrition – Beyond the statistics a ten year retrospective study. BMC Medical Education, 13, 13. 2013.
[5]	American Association of Medical Colleges. https://www.aamc.org/data/tuitionandstudentfees/. [Accessed June 2018]
[6]	American Medical Students Association. https://www.amsa.org/suicide-is-more-common-in-medical-school-than-in-any-other-school-setting/ June 21, 2017. [Accessed June 2018.
[7]	Kowarski, I. US News. https://www.usnews.com/education/best-graduate-schools/top-medical-schools/articles/2016-10-14/find-medical-schools-that-match-your-learning-style Oct. 14, 2016. [Accessed May 2018].
[8]	Short White Coats. Com. http://shortwhitecoats.com/2015/a-map-of-all-medical-schools-in-the-united-states. May 15, 2015. [Accessed April 2018]
[9]	Mann, S. American Association of Medical Colleges News. https://news.aamc.org/medical-education/article/new-aamc-research-reaffirms-looming-physician-shor/. March 14, 2017. [Accessed June 2108]
[10]	UT Southwestern Education. http://www.utsouthwestern.edu/newsroom/articles/year-2017/medical-students-shine.html. July 7, 2017. Accessed May 2018.
[11]	Kowarski, I. 2016. Find medical schools that match your learning style. http://www.usnews.com/topics/author/ilana-kowarski. [Accessed June 2018].
[12]	Cooles, P.E., Harrigan-Vital, M. and Laville, A. 2014. Student performance and grading changes in a systems-based curriculum. Medical Education Online, 19. 2014.
[13]	Franco, K. https://www.usnews.com/education/blogs/medical-school-admissions-doctor/2015/10/13/tips-for-selecting-the-right-medical-school-curriculum. Oct. 13, 2015. [Accessed May 2015].
[14]	Quora. https://www.quora.com/In-medical-schools-with-pass-fail-system-how-do-residencies-discriminate-the-good-candidates-from-the-bad-ones. [Accessed February 2018].
[15]	Spring, L., Robillard, D., Gehlbach, L. and Simas, T.A. Impact of pass/fail grading on medical students’ well-being and academic outcomes. Medical Education, 45(9), 867-877. 2011.
[16]	Lewis, C.A., Hiatt, J.R., Wilkerson, L., Tillou, A., Parker, N.H. and Hines, J. Numerical versus pass/fail scoring on the USMLE: what do medical students and residents want and why? J Grad Med Educ, 3(1), 59-66. 2011. school. Family Medicine, 50(2), 128-131. 2018.
[17]	Meit, S.S., Borges, N.J. and Early, L.A. Personality profiles of incoming male and female medical students: Results of a multi-site 9-year study. Medical Education Online, 12(1), 4462. 2007.
[18]	Alkan, M.L. The global medical school, 2020. Medical Teacher, 22(5), 527-530, 2000.
[19]	Kucheryavenko, O. Shortcomings of medical education in developing countries. https://consumers.cochrane.org/blog/shortcomings-medical-education-developing-countries. [Accessed July 2018].
[20]	Philibert, I. International medical education outreach: Benefits for US medical education and practice. An interview with Joseph Kolars, MD. Journal of Graduate Medical Education, 1(1), 162-163, 2009.