Referees’ Decision Making Behavior and the Sport Home Advantage Phenomenon

Geoff P Lovell^1, , Ross Newell² and John K Parker²

¹School of Social Sciences, Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences, University of the Sunshine Coast, Queensland, Australia

²Faculty of Sport, Health & Social Care, University of Gloucestershire, Gloucester, UK

Cite this paper:
Geoff P Lovell, Ross Newell and John K Parker. Referees’ Decision Making Behavior and the Sport Home Advantage Phenomenon. Research in Psychology and Behavioral Sciences. 2014; 2(1):1-5. doi: 10.12691/rpbs-2-1-1

Abstract

The aim of this investigation was to examine the decision making behavior of soccer officials (referees) in English Premiership matches to establish whether a bias, as perceived by the media and professional players, does or does not exist. Using notational analysis, this investigation used three trained professional soccer referees to assess the decisions made by match-day officials in favor of home and away teams during the entirety of ten-matched Premiership soccer fixtures. Results revealed a non-significant trend, x2 = .843, p > .05, where the number of decisions awarded by the referees favored the home team. However, significant differences were observed in the number of contentious and incorrect / missed decisions awarded in favor of the home teams compared to away teams, χ² = 4.17, p < .05 and χ² = 3.86, p < .05, respectively. Conclusions from this investigation indicate that soccer referees exhibit bias in favor of home teams and suggest that referee decision making behavior may be one mechanistic explanation of the home advantage phenomenon in soccer.

Keywords:
home advantage referees soccer decision making

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References:

[1]	Mascarenhas, D.R.D., Collins, D. and Mortimer, P., “The art of reason versus the exactness of science in elite refereeing: Comments on Plessner and Betsch (2001)”, Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 24, 328-333, 2001.
[2]	Mason, C., and Lovell, G., “Attitudes, expectations and demands of English Premier League Soccer Association referees”, Journal of Football Studies, 3, 88-102, 2000.
[3]	Courneya, K.S., and. Carron, A.V. “The home advantage in sport competitions: A literature review”, Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 14, 13-27, 1992.
[4]	Barnett, V., and Hilditch, S., “The effect of an artificial pitch surface on home team performance in football (soccer)”, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, 156, 39-50, 1993.
[5]	Clarke, S.R., and Norman, J. M., “Home advantage of individual clubs in English soccer”, The Statistician, 44, 509-521, 1995
[6]	Thorn, J., and Palmer, P., The hidden game of baseball. Doubleday, New York, 1985.
[7]	McGuire, E.J., Courneya, K.S., Widmeyer, N.W., and Carron, A.V., “Aggression as a potential mediator of the home advantage in professional ice hockey”, Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 14, 148-158, 1992.
[8]	Greer, D.L., “Spectator booing and the home advantage: a study of social influence in the basketball arena”, Social Psychology Quarterly, 46, 252-261, 1983.
[9]	Snyder, E.E., and Purdy, D.A., “The home advantage in collegiate basketball”, Sociology of Sport Journal, 2, 352-356 1985.
[10]	Varca, P.E., “An analysis of home and away game performance of male college basketball teams”, Journal of Sport Psychology, 2, 245-257, 1980.
[11]	Nevill, A.M., and Holder, R.L., “Home advantage in sport: an overview of studies on the advantage of playing at home”, Journal of Sports Medicine, 28, 221-236, 1999.
[12]	Edwards, J., and Archambault, D., The home-field advantage: Sports, games and play: social and psychological viewpoints. Erlbaum Associates, 1989.
[13]	Jones, M.B., “The home advantage in individual sports: An augmented review”, Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 14, 397-404, 2013.
[14]	Page, L., and Page, K., “The second leg home advantage: Evidence from European football cup competitions”, Journal of Sports Sciences, 25, 14, 1547-1556, 2007.
[15]	Carron, A.V., Loughhead T.M., and Bray, S.R., “The home advantage in sport competitions: Courneya and Carron’s (1992) conceptual framework a decade later”, Journal of Sports Sciences, 23, 395-407, 2005.
[16]	Nevill, A.M., Newell, S.M., and Gale, S., “Factors associated with home advantage in English and Scottish soccer matches”, Journal of Sports Sciences, 14, 181-186, 1996.
[17]	Agnew, G.A., and Carron, A.V., “Crowd effects and the home advantage”, InternationalJournal of Sport Psychology, 25, 53-62, 1994.
[18]	Salminen, S., “The effect of the audience on the home advantage”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 76, 1123-1128, 1993.
[19]	Strauss, B., “Social facilitation in motor tasks: a review of research and theory”, Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 3, 237-256, 2002.
[20]	Smith, D.R., Ciacciarelli, A., Serzan, J., and Lambert, D., “Travel and the home advantage in professional sports”, Sociology of Sport Journal, 17, 364-385, 2000.
[21]	Brown, T.D., Van Raalte, J.L., Brewer, B.W., Winter, C.R., and Cornelius, A.A., “World cup soccer home advantage”, Journal of Sport Behavior, 25, 134-144, 2002.
[22]	Pollard, R., “Home advantage in soccer: A retrospective analysis”, Journal of Sports Sciences, 4, 237-248, 1986.
[23]	Loughead, T.M., Carron, A.V., Bray, S.R., and Kim, A., “Facility familiarity and the home advantage in professional sports”, International Journal of Sport Psychology and Exercise Psychology, 1, 264-274, 2003.
[24]	Moore, J.C., and Brylinsky, J., “Facility familiarity and the home advantage”, Journal of Sport Behavior, 18, 302-311, 1995.
[25]	Lovell, G.P., Newell, R., and Parker, J.K., “Home advantage and critical psychological states: The interaction between venue and subsequent result”, International Journal of Sports Sciences and Physical Education, 2, 57-63, 2011.
[26]	Balmer, N.J., Nevill, A.M., and Lane, A.M., “Do judges enhance home advantage in European championship boxing?” Journal of Sports Sciences, 23, 409-416, 2005.
[27]	Balmer, N.J., Nevill, A.M., and Williams, M., “Home advantage in the Winter Olympics (1908-1998)”, Journal of Sports Sciences, 19, 129-139, 2001.
[28]	Balmer, N.J., Nevill, A.M., and Williams, M., “Modeling home advantage in the Summer Olympic games”, Journal of Sports Sciences, 21, 469-478, 2003.
[29]	Nevill, A M., Balmer, N.J., and Williams, A.M., “The influence of crowd noise and experience upon refereeing decisions in football”, Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 3, 261-272, 2002.
[30]	Waters, A., and Lovell, G.P., “An examination of the homefield advantage in a professional English soccer team from a psychological standpoint”, Journal of Football Studies, 5, 46-59, 2002.
[31]	Hughes, M., and Franks, I., Notational analysis in sport. E & FN Spon, 1997.
[32]	Hughes, M., and Franks, I., Notational analysis of sport: Systems for better coaching and performance in sport.Routledge, New York, 2004.
[33]	Thirer, J., and Rampey, M., “Effects of abusive spectator behaviour on the performance of home and visiting intercollegiate basketball teams”, Perceptual and Motor Skills, 48, 1047-1053, 1979.
[34]	Rainey, D., “Sources of stress among baseball and softball umpires”, Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 7, 1-10, 1995.
[35]	Lehman, D.R., and Reifman, A., “Spectator influence on basketball officiating”, The Journal of Social Psychology, 127, 673-675, 1987.
[36]	Glamser, F.D., “Contest location, player misconduct, and race: A case from English soccer”, Journal of Sport Behaviour, 13, 41-49, 1990.