Fertilizer Management and Bean Density Drive Productivity–profitability Trade-offs in Maize–common Bean Intercropping on a Tropical Andosol in the Western Highlands of Cameroon

Hassan Yap Mfouapon^1, , Adalbert Onana Adibime², Jean Bosco Onguene³, Primus Azinwi Tamfuh^{2, 4}, Paulin Nana¹, Evariste Desire Moundjeu⁴, Georges Simplice Kameni Kouedeu⁴, Cynthia-rita Ngwahimo Ngnokam⁴, Ismael Foukena Yandintoum⁴ and Alexis Boukong⁴

¹Department of Agriculture, Livestock and Fisheries Sciences, Higher Institute of Agriculture, Forestry, Water and Environment, University of Ebolowa, P.O. Box 118, Ebolowa, Cameroon

²Department of Crop Production Technology, College of Technology, University of Bamenda, P.O. Box 39, Bambili, Cameroon

³Department of Agronomy, OCP Cameroon, P.O. Box 3168, Douala, Cameroon

⁴Department of Soil Science, Faculty of Agronomy and Agricultural Sciences, University of Dschang, P.O. Box 222, Dschang, Cameroon

Cite this paper:
Hassan Yap Mfouapon, Adalbert Onana Adibime, Jean Bosco Onguene, Primus Azinwi Tamfuh, Paulin Nana, Evariste Desire Moundjeu, Georges Simplice Kameni Kouedeu, Cynthia-rita Ngwahimo Ngnokam, Ismael Foukena Yandintoum and Alexis Boukong. Fertilizer Management and Bean Density Drive Productivity–profitability Trade-offs in Maize–common Bean Intercropping on a Tropical Andosol in the Western Highlands of Cameroon. World Journal of Agricultural Research. 2026; 14(3):81-96. doi: 10.12691/wjar-14-3-1

Abstract

The intensification of maize (Zea mays L.)–common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) intercropping requires balancing nutrient supply, interspecific competition and returns to fertilizer investment. The individual and interactive effects of NPK fertilizer regime, supplemental urea, and bean density on system productivity and economic performance on a tropical Andosol of the Cameroon Western Highlands were evaluated. Two independent field experiments were conducted on separate fields (C1: April–July; C2: July–October) using a split-split-plot design with three replicates. Five NPK regimes (0; 300 and 600 kg ha⁻¹ of 20-10-10 + 6SO₃; and 300 and 600 kg ha⁻¹ of 14-23-14 + 5S + 1B₂O₃) were combined with 0 or 100 kg ha⁻¹ urea and three cropping systems: sole maize at 55,555 plants ha⁻¹ (S1), and maize at the same density intercropped with bean at 22,222 (S2; two plants hill⁻¹) or 33,333 plants ha⁻¹ (S3; three plants hill⁻¹), while maintaining the same spatial arrangement. Mean combined physical grain yield was 7.384 t ha⁻¹ in C1 and 6.746 t ha⁻¹ in C2; these differences were considered descriptive because the experiments were conducted on separate fields. The NPK × urea × cropping system interaction significantly affected combined physical grain yield in both C1 (P = 0.037) and C2 (P = 0.028). NPK14_600 × U100 × S2 produced the highest yields, reaching 9.476 and 8.295 t ha⁻¹, respectively. Increasing bean density by 50% from S2 to S3 reduced bean yield by 8.5% in C1 and 14.0% in C2 and further reduced maize yield. The productivity optimum, however, did not coincide with the economic optimum. The aggregated economic assessment identified NPK14_300 × U0 × S2 as having the highest benefit-to-cost ratio (BCR = 2.59; fertilizer economic return = 158.85%), compared with a BCR of 1.33 for the highest-yielding strategy, NPK14_600 × U100 × S2. Thus, among the configurations tested, S2 was common to the strategies achieving the highest physical productivity and economic return, whereas fertilizer intensity determined the trade-off between these objectives.

Keywords:
Andosol maize–common bean intercropping planting density mineral fertilization economic return Cameroon Western Highlands

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References:

[1]	Vanlauwe, B., Coyne, D., Gockowski, J., Hauser, S., Huising, J., Masso, C., Nziguheba, G., Schut, M. and Van Asten, P., "Sustainable intensification and the African smallholder development agenda," International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability, 12 (3), 212-238, 2014.
[2]	Vanlauwe, B., Descheemaeker, K., Giller, K.E., Huising, J., Merckx, R., Nziguheba, G. and Zingore, S., "Integrated soil fertility management in Sub-Saharan Africa: unravelling K-meaning," Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 15, 8-15, 2015.
[3]	FAO, IFAD, UNICEF, WFP and WHO, The State of Food Security and Nutrition in the World 2022. Repurposing food and agricultural policies to make healthy diets more affordable, FAO, Rome, Italy, 2022, 260 p.
[4]	Bedoussac, L., Journet, E.P., Hauggaard-Nielsen, H., Naudin, C., Corre-Hellou, G., Prieur, L., Housseker, A. and Justes, E., "Ecological principles underlying the increase of productivity achieved by cereal-grain legume intercrops in organic farming: a review," Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 35 (3), 911-935, 2015.
[5]	Li, C., Hoffland, E., Kuyper, T.W., Yu, Y., Zhang, C., Li, H., Zhang, F. and Werf, W. van der, "Syndromes of production in intercropping: a meta-analysis," Field Crops Research, 291, 108796, 2023.
[6]	Willey, R.W., "Intercropping—its importance and research needs. Part 1. Competition and yield advantages," Field Crop Abstracts, 32 (1), 1-10, 1979.
[7]	Hauggaard-Nielsen, H., Jornsgaard, B., Kinane, J. and Jensen, E.S., "Grain legume-cereal intercropping: The qualitative upgrade of competition, resource utilization and yield stability," Field Crops Research, 107 (2), 161-169, 2008.
[8]	Brooker, R.W., Karley, A.J., Newton, A.C., Pakeman, R.J. and Schöb, C., "Facilitation and crop intercropping: using habitat modification to improve crop yield," Journal of Ecology, 103 (1), 56-65, 2015.
[9]	Bybee-Finley, K.A. and Ryan, M.R., "Advancing intercropping research and practices in temperate agricultural systems," Agronomy, 8 (6), 80, 2018.
[10]	Tittonell, P. and Giller, K.E., "When yield gaps are poverty traps: The paradigm of ecological intensification in African agriculture," Field Crops Research, 143, 76-90, 2013.
[11]	Giller, K.E., Hijbeek, R., Andersson, J.A. and Summers, D.M., "Regenerative agriculture: An agronomic perspective," Outlook on Agriculture, 50 (1), 13-25, 2021.
[12]	ten Berge, H.F.M., Hijbeek, R., van Loon, M.P., Rurinda, J., Tesfaye, K., Zingore, S., Kihara, J., Vanlauwe, B. and van Ittersum, M.K., "Maize crop nutrient requirements in Sub-Saharan Africa," Field Crops Research, 235, 27-39, 2019.
[13]	Broughton, W.J., Hernandez, G., Blair, M., Beebe, S., Gepts, P. and Vanderleyden, J., "Beans (Phaseolus spp.)-model food legumes," Plant and Soil, 252 (1), 55-128, 2003.
[14]	Beebe, S., Rao, I., Mukankusi, C. and Buruchara, R., "Improving common bean productivity under climate change in Sub-Saharan Africa," Frontiers in Physiology, 3, 498, 2012.
[15]	Djeugap, J.F., Fontem, D.A. and Tapondjou, L.A., "Assessment of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) production constraints and cropping practices in the Western Highlands of Cameroon," International Journal of Agricultural Policy and Research, 2 (6), 210-218, 2014.
[16]	Tening, A.S., Foba-Tendo, J.N., Yakum-Ntai, Y. and Yerima, B.P.K., "Assessment of soil fertility status in Foumbot Western Highlands of Cameroon," International Journal of Soil Science, 15 (1), 12-22, 2020.
[17]	Mfouapon, Y.H., Azinwi Tamfuh, P., Onana, A.A., Jules, A.L., Etienne, M., Evariste, D.M., Cynthia-Rita, N.N., Ismael, F.Y. and Alexis, B., "Interactive effect of organic manures, mineral fertilizers and seasons on agronomic parameters of intercropped maize (Zea mays L.), common beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) on Oxisol in the Noun Valley (Cameroon Western Highlands)," African Journal of Agricultural Research, 20 (8), 702-718, 2024.
[18]	Lithourgidis, A.S., Dordas, C.A., Damalas, C.A. and Vlachostergios, D.N., "Annual intercrops: an alternative pathway for sustainable agriculture," Australian Journal of Crop Science, 5 (4), 396-410, 2011.
[19]	Maitra, S., Hossain, A., Bregaglio, S. and Pramanick, B., "Intercropping—A low-input agricultural strategy for food and environmental security," Agronomy, 11 (2), 343, 2021.
[20]	Chimonyo, V.G.P., Modi, A.T. and Mabhaudhi, T., "Perspective on intra-specific competition in cereal-legume intercropping systems," Agronomy Journal, 112 (1), 220-234, 2020.
[21]	Feng, L., Raza, M.A., Chen, Y., Khalid, M.H.R., Meraj, T.A., Ahsan, F., Fan, Y., Du, J., Wu, X., Song, C., Liu, W.G. and Yang, W., "Narrow-wide row planting pattern improves light interception and seed yield in maize-soybean intercropping systems," Field Crops Research, 270, 108214, 2021.
[22]	Raza, M.A., Cui, L., Khan, I., Din, A.M.U., Chen, G., Ansar, M., Ahmed, M. and Yang, W., "Compact maize canopy maintains symmetry and improves radiation use efficiency in maize-soybean intercropping," Frontiers in Plant Science, 12, 640191, 2021.
[23]	Zhang, D., Sun, Z., Zhang, Y., Bai, W., Wang, Q., Liu, Z. and Zhang, L., "Maize-soybean strip intercropping increases system productivity by improving light interception and dry matter accumulation," Field Crops Research, 262, 108020, 2021.
[24]	Stomph, T.J., Dordas, C., Baranger, A., de Rijk, J., Dong, B., Evers, J.B., Gu, C., Li, L. and Zhang, C., "Designing intercropping systems for multi-functionality: Opportunities and challenges," Frontiers in Plant Science, 14, 1225883, 2023.
[25]	Shoji, S., Nanzyo, M. and Dahlgren, R., Volcanic Ash Soils: Genesis, Properties and Utilization, Developments in Soil Science 21, Elsevier, Amsterdam, Netherlands, 1993, 288 p.
[26]	Dahlgren, R.A., Saigusa, M. and Ugolini, F.C., "The nature, properties and management of volcanic ash soils," Advances in Agronomy, 82, 113-182, 2004.
[27]	Yerima, B.P.K. and Van Ranst, E., Major Soil Classification Systems: A basis for understanding soil resources for Africa and the Republic of Cameroon, Éditions CLE, Yaoundé, Cameroun, 2005, 392 p.
[28]	IUSS Working Group WRB, World Reference Base for Soil Resources. International soil classification system for naming soils and creating legends for soil maps, 4th ed., International Union of Soil Sciences (IUSS), Vienna, Austria, 2022.
[29]	Nintije, G., Yerima, B.P.K. and Van Ranst, E., "Phosphate sorption characteristics and availability in tropical Andosols of the Central African Highlands," Geoderma Regional, 32, e00612, 2023.
[30]	Nassary, E.K., Frederick, C. and Kalala, A., "Nitrogen fixed by legumes and its economic value in cereal-legume intercropping systems," Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition, 20 (4), 2201-2218, 2020.
[31]	Desta, B., Amare, G. and Astatke, A., "Boron and sulfur fertilization improves grain yield, nodulation and economic returns of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.)," Heliyon, 7 (5), e07012, 2021.
[32]	Bipfubusa, M., Tening, A.S. and Yerima, B.P.K., "Balanced fertilization including sulfur and boron enhances maize and legume productivity on volcanic soils of Central Africa," Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition, 22 (4), 3105-3118, 2022.
[33]	Kihara, J., Bolo, P., Kinyua, M., Rurinda, J. and Zingore, S., "Micronutrient fertilization increases cereal and legume yields in Sub-Saharan Africa: A meta-analysis," Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 43 (2), 28, 2023.
[34]	Anyoni, V.P., Chimonyo, V.G.P., Mabhaudhi, T. and Modi, A.T., "Optimizing water and nutrient use efficiency in cereal-legume intercropping under variable rainfall regimes," Agricultural Water Management, 291, 108620, 2024.
[35]	FAO, Financial and Economic Analysis of Fertilizer Use and Agriculture Inputs, Land and Water Development Division, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome, Italy, 2005, 89 p.
[36]	Kaho, F., Yemefack, M., Feujio-Teguefouet, P. and Tchantchaouang, J.C., "Effet combiné des feuilles de Calliandra calothyrsus et des engrais minéraux sur le rendement du maïs et les propriétés d'un sol ferrallitique au Centre Cameroun," Tropicultura, 29 (1), 39-45, 2011.
[37]	Sheahan, M. and Barrett, C.B., "Ten striking facts about agricultural input use in Sub-Saharan Africa," Food Policy, 67, 12-25, 2017.
[38]	Coulibaly, A., Bagayoko, M. and Kouressy, M., "Economic evaluation of mineral fertilizer application in sorghum-cowpea intercropping systems in West Africa," African Journal of Agricultural Research, 12 (14), 1180-1191, 2017.
[39]	Worku, M., De Groote, H. and Munyua, B., "Financial profitability and risk analysis of mineral fertilizer application in smallholder maize production systems," Agricultural Economics, 51 (4), 543-558, 2020.
[40]	Girma, R., Bedadi, B. and Worku, W., "Economic profitability of mineral fertilizer use in smallholder cereal-legume intercropping systems under nutrient-limited soils," Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems, 125 (2), 145-160, 2023.
[41]	Rurinda, J., Mapfumo, P., van Wijk, M.T., Mtambanengwe, F., Rufino, M.C., Chikowo, R. and Giller, K.E., "Comparative profitability and risk assessment of mineral fertilizer practices in smallholder farming systems," Agricultural Systems, 204, 103540, 2023.
[42]	Wandji, R., Contribution à l'étude pétrologique et géochimique du volcanisme de la région de Foumbot (Ouest-Cameroun), Thèse de Doctorat de 3ème cycle, Université de Yaoundé, Cameroun, 1985, 185 p.
[43]	Kenzong, B., Bitondo, D., Tamfuh, P.A., Kameni, G.S.K., Vounang, J.G., Enang, R.K., Temgoua, E. and Bitom, D., "Assessing and Mapping Land Suitability Units for Maize (Zea mays L) Production Using Integrated DEMATELANP Model and GIS in the Foumbot Agricultural Basin (Cameroon Western Highlands)," Journal of Geoscience and Environment Protection, 10, 57-85, 2022.
[44]	Ngandeu, A.D., Yerima, B.P.K. and Van Ranst, E., "Spatial distribution and pedogenic characterization of toposequence soils in the Noun Plain, Western Highlands of Cameroon," Journal of Soil Science and Environmental Management, 7 (8), 112-125, 2016.
[45]	Pauwels, J.M., Van Ranst, E., Verloo, M. and Mvondo Ze, A., Manuel d'analyse de sol et de plante : méthodes de laboratoire et de contrôle de qualité, Publications Agricoles n° 28, AGCD, Bruxelles, Belgique, 1992, 265 p.
[46]	Cairns, J.E., Sonder, K., Zaidi, P.H., Verhulst, N., Mahlein, A.K., Choudhary, A.K., Nair, S.K., Babu, R., Thaitamu, D.A. and Prasanna, B.M., "Maize production in a changing climate: impacts, adaptation, and mitigation strategies," Advances in Agronomy, 114, 1-58, 2012.
[47]	Hatfield, J.L. and Dold, C., "Water-use efficiency: advances and challenges in agricultural systems," Agronomy, 9 (3), 103, 2019.
[48]	Cameron, K.C., Di, H.J. and Moir, J.L., "Nitrogen losses from the soil/plant system: a review," Annals of Applied Biology, 162 (2), 145-173, 2013.
[49]	Quemada, M., Barba, M., Nguyen, B.T. and Gabriel, J.L., "Strategies for improving nitrogen use efficiency in irrigated agricultural systems," Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 174, 1-10, 2013.
[50]	Vanlauwe, B., Bationo, A., Chianu, J., Giller, K.E., Merckx, R., Mokwunye, U., Ohiokpehai, O., Pypers, P., Tabo, R., Shepherd, K.D., Smaling, E.M.A., Woomer, P.L. and Zingore, S., "Integrated soil fertility management: operational definition and consequences for implementation and dissemination," Agronomy Journal, 102 (3), 890-893, 2010.
[51]	Fageria, N.K., Baligar, V.C. and Jones, C.A., Growth and Mineral Nutrition of Field Crops, 3rd ed., CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA, 2011, 584 p.
[52]	Marschner, P., Marschner's Mineral Nutrition of Higher Plants, 3rd ed., Academic Press, San Diego, CA, USA, 2012, 651 p.