The Impact of a Sense of Belonging on the Health-Related Quality of Life among the Elderly in New York City

Hyangmi Kim^1, , Jacob M. Eubank¹, John Orazem², D.J. Oberlin¹, Elgloria A. Harrison^{2, 3} and Collette M. Brown³

¹Department of Exercise Sciences and Recreation, CUNY, Lehman College, Bronx, United States of America

²School of Health Sciences, Human Services, and Nursing, Lehman College, Bronx, United States of America

³Department of Health Equity, Administration & Technology, CUNY, Lehman College, Bronx, United States of America

Cite this paper:
Hyangmi Kim, Jacob M. Eubank, John Orazem, D.J. Oberlin, Elgloria A. Harrison and Collette M. Brown. The Impact of a Sense of Belonging on the Health-Related Quality of Life among the Elderly in New York City. American Journal of Public Health Research. 2025; 13(1):20-37. doi: 10.12691/ajphr-13-1-4

Abstract

This study aims to enhance the existing literature on the sense of belonging by exploring its impact on health-related quality of life among older adults in New York City. It also examines how this sense of belonging varies across different demographic characteristics and health conditions. We conducted a cross-sectional study using the Sense of Belonging Instrument-Psychological State (SOBI-P) and Health-related Quality of Life-4 (HRQOL-4) to collect online data from 378 participants, all aged 60 and above, residing in the five boroughs of New York City. Our findings indicate that males have a lower sense of belonging, while Black/African Americans scored significantly higher than those in the 'other' category. Additionally, individuals with hearing and visual impairments scored significantly lower on the sense of belonging compared to those with other health conditions. The study also indicates that a stronger sense of belonging is linked to better perceived health. Conversely, it found that a lower sense of belonging is associated with more days of poor physical and mental health, which in turn are connected to fewer days of engaging in usual activities. Recommendations to enhance the sense of belonging among older adults are provided.

Keywords:
Sense of Belonging belongingness Quality of life Health-related quality of life NYC

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References:

[1]	Hawkley, L. C., and Cacioppo, J. T., “Loneliness matters: A theoretical and empirical review of consequences and mechanisms”. Annals of Behavioral Medicine. 40(2): p.218–227, 2010.
[2]	Röhr, S., Löbner, M., Gühne, U., Heser, K., Kleineidam, L., Pentzek, M., and Riedel-Heller, S. G., “Changes in social network size are associated with cognitive changes in the oldest-old”. Frontiers in psychiatry. 11: p.330. 2020.
[3]	Wrzus C., Hänel, M., Wagner, J., and Neyer, F.J., “Social network changes and life events across the life span: A meta-analysis”. Psychological Bulletin. 139(1): p.53–80, 2013.
[4]	Okun, M. A., and Keith, V. M., “Effects of positive and negative social exchanges with various sources on depressive symptoms in younger and older adults”. Journal of Gerontology, 53B (1): p.4–20, 1998.
[5]	Tiilikaine, E., and Seppanen, M., “Lost and unfulfilled relationships behind emotional loneliness in old age”. Aging & Society, 37(5): p.1068-1088, 2017.
[6]	National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. Social Isolation and Loneliness in Older Adults: Opportunities for the Health Care System. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press, 2020.
[7]	Pinquart, M., and Sorensen, S., “Influences on loneliness in older adults: A meta-analysis”, Basic and applied social psychology. 23(4): p.245-266, 2001.
[8]	Gerlach, L.B., Solway, E.S., and Malani, P.N. “Social isolation and loneliness in older adults”. JAM, 331(23): 2058, 2024.
[9]	Gallup National Health and Wellbeing Index. Loneliness in U.S. Subsides from Pandemic High. 2023.
[10]	Baumeister, R. F., and Leary, M. R., “The need to belong: Desire for interpersonal attachments as a fundamental human motivation”. Psychological Bulletin, 117(3): p. 497–529, 1995.
[11]	Hagerty, B. M., Lynch-Sauer, J., Patusky, K. L., Bouwsema, M., and Collier, P., “Sense of belonging: A vital mental health concept”. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, 6(3): p.172–177, 1992.
[12]	Lim, M, H., Allen, K., Furlong, M. J., Craig, H., & Smith, D. C., “Introducing a dual continuum model of belonging and loneliness”. Australian Journal of Psychology, 73(1): p81-86, 2021.
[13]	Shankar, A., McMunn, A., Banks, J., and Steptoe, A., “Loneliness, social isolation, behavioral and biological health indicators in older adults.” Health Psychology, 30(4), p.377-385, 2011.
[14]	Allen, K., Arsian, G., Craig, H., Arefi, S., Yaghoobzadeh, A., and Sharif-Nia, H., “The psychometric evaluation of the sense of belonging instrument (SOBI) with Iranian older adults”. BMC Geriatrics, 21(1): p.211, 2021.
[15]	Kitchen, P., Williams, A., and Chowhan, J., “Sense of community belonging and health in Canada: a regional analysis”. Social Indicators Research: An International and Interdisciplinary Journal for Quality-of-Life Measurement, 107(1): p.103-126, 2012.
[16]	Choenarom, C., Wiliams, R, A. and Hagerty, B, M., “The role of sense of belonging and social support on stress and depression in individuals with depression”. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, 19(1): p.18-29, 2005.
[17]	Over Zero and The American Immigration Council. The Belonging Barometer: The State of Belonging in America (Revised ed.). Over Zero, 2024.
[18]	Suss R, Stratton N, Caton J, Norman C., “Social determinants of mental health among New York City adults.” New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene: Epi Data Brief (139); November 2023.
[19]	Birditt, K. S., Turkelson, A., Fingerman, K. L., Polenick, C. A., and Oya, A. “Age differences in stress, life changes, and social ties during the COVID-19 pandemic: Implications for psychological well-being”. The Gerontologist, 61(2): 2021.
[20]	Fingerman, K. L., Ng, Y. T., Zhang, S., Britt, K., Colera, G., Birditt, K. S., and Charles, S. T., “Living alone during COVID-19: Social con- tact and emotional well-being among older adults”. The Journals of Gerontology: Series B, 76(3): e116–e121, 2021.
[21]	Kredel, A. C., and Perry, B. L, “The impact of sheltering in place during the COVID-19 pandemic on older adults' social and mental well-being”. The Journals of Gerontology: Series B, 76(2): e53–e58, 2021.
[22]	Chen, A. T., Ge, S., Cho, S., Teng, A. K., Chu, F., Demiris, G., and Zaslavsky. O, “Reactions to COVID-19, information and technology use, and social connectedness among older adults with pre-frailty and frailty”. Geriatric Nursing, 42(1): p.188–195, 2021.
[23]	Ejiri, M., Kawai, H., Kera, T., Ihara, K., Fujiwara, Y., Watanabe, Y., Hirano, H., Kim, H. and Obuchi, S, “Exercise as a coping strategy and its impact on the psychological well-being of Japanese community-dwelling older adults during the COVID-19 pandemic: A longitudinal study”. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 57: p.102054. 2021.
[24]	Siette, J., Dodds, L., Seaman, K., Wuthrich, V., Johnco, C., Earl, J., Dawes, P. and Westbrook, J. I, “The impact of COVID-19 on the quality of life of older adults receiving community-based aged care”. Australasian Journal on Ageing, 40(1): 84–89, 2021.
[25]	Macdonald, B. and Hülür, G, “Well-being and loneliness in Swiss older adults during the COVID-19 pandemic: The role of social relationships”. The Gerontologist, 61(2): p. 240–250, 2021.
[26]	Karimi, M. and Brazier, J, “Health, Health-Related Quality of Life, and Quality of Life: What is the Difference?”. PharmacoEconomics, 34: p.645–649, 2016.
[27]	Mohammed F., Shahin M., Youness E., Hassan H. Survivorship in Women Undergoing Gynecological and Breast Cancer Treatment in Upper Egypt: The Impact of Quality of Life Improvement Educational Program”. American Research Journal of Gynaecology. 2018; 2(1): 1-28.
[28]	Mostafa H., Yousef F., Hassan H. Health Related Quality of Life Educational Interventions: Effect on Chronic Hepatitis C Patients'. Saudi Journal of Nursing and Health Care. 2018; 1(2): 56-67.
[29]	Nady F., Said M., Youness E., Hassan H. Effect of Nursing Intervention Program on Quality of Life Improvement for Women Undergoing Gynecological and Breast Cancer Treatment. Assuit Scientific Nursing Journal, 2018; 6(15): 62-77.
[30]	Hassan H & Farag D. The impact of polycystic ovary syndrome on women’s quality of life: Nursing guidelines for.
[31]	Cavlak, U., Yağcı, N., Aslan, U.B. and Ekici, G, “A new tool measuring health-related quality of life (HRQOL): The effects of musculoskeletal pain in a group of older Turkish people”. Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics, 49(2): p. 298-303, 2009.
[32]	Cotterell, N., Buffel, T., Nazroo, J. and Qualter, P, “Loneliness among older ethnic minority people: exploring the role of structural disadvantage and place using a co-research methodology”. Ethnic and Racial Studies, p. 1–23, 2024.
[33]	Hagerty, B. M., Lynch-Sauer, J., Patusky, K. L., Bouwsema, M., and Collier, P, “Sense of belonging: A vital mental health concept”. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, 6(3): p. 172–177. 1992.
[34]	Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. CDC HRQOL–14 Healthy days measure: Healthy days core module (CDC HRQOL– 4), 2018.
[35]	Zeileis, A., Kleiber, C. and Jackman, C, “Regression Models for Count Data in R”. Journal of Statistical Software 27(8): 2008.
[36]	Mandel, M, “Simulation-Based Confidence Intervals for Functions with Complicated Derivatives”. The American Statistician. 67(2): 2013.
[37]	Yee, T.W, “The VGAM Package for Categorical Data Analysis”. Journal of Statistical Software. 32(10): p.1-34, 2010.
[38]	Cornwell, E., & Cagney, K. A. “Assessment of neighborhood context in a nationally representative study”. The Journals of Gerontology. Series B, 69(8): S51–S63, 2014.
[39]	Levasseur, M., Roy, M., Michallet, B., St-Hilaire, F., Maltais, D., and Genereux, M, “Associations between resilience, community belonging, and social participation among community-dwelling older adults: results from the eastern townships population health survey”. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, 98(12): p. 2422 – 2432, 2017.
[40]	Clark, J.A., Engelman, M., Schultz, A.A., Bersch, A.J., and Malecki, K. “Sense of neighborhood belonging and health: Geographic, racial, and socioeconomic variation in Wisconsin”. Frontiers in Public Health, 12: p.1376672. 2024.
[41]	Gonyea, J. G., Curley, A., Melekis, K., and Lee, Y. “Perceptions of neighborhood safety and depressive symptoms among older minority urban subsidized housing residents: the mediating effect of sense of community belonging”. Aging & Mental Health, 22(12): p.1564–1569. 2017.
[42]	Birditt, K.S., Turkelson, A., Fingerman, K.L., Polenick, C.A. and Oya, A. “Age differences in stress, life changes, and social ties during the COVID-19 pandemic: Implications for psychological well-being”. The Gerontologist, 61(2): p.205-216, 2021.
[43]	Huang, A.R et al, “Loneliness and social network characteristics among older adults with hearing loss in the achieve study”. The Journal of Gerontology: Series A. 79(2): glad196, 2024.
[44]	Shukla, A et al., “Hearing Loss, Loneliness, and Social Isolation: A Systematic Review”. Otolaryngology-Heat and Neck Surgery. 162(5): p.622-633, 2020.
[45]	Chu, H.-Y. and Chan, H.-S., “Loneliness and social support among the middle-aged and elderly people with visual impairment”. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(21): p.14600, 2022.
[46]	Prezza, M., Amici, M., Roberti, T. and Tedeschi, G, “Sense of community referred to the whole town: Its relations with neighboring, loneliness, life satisfaction, and area of residence”. Journal of Community Psychology, 29(1): p.29-52, 2001.
[47]	Prieto-Flores, M.E., Forjaz, M.J., Fernandez-Mayoralas, G., Rojo-Perez, F. and Martinez-Martin, P, “Factors associated with loneliness of noninstitutionalized and institutionalized older adults”. Journal of Aging and Health, 23(1): p.177-194, 2011.
[48]	Allan, I., Ammi, M. and Dedewanou, F.A., The impact of sense of belonging on health: Canadian evidence. Applied Economics. p. 1-13, 2024.
[49]	Michalski, C.A., Diemert, L. M., Helliwell, J. F., Goel, V., and Rosella, C. R, “Relationship between sense of community belonging and self-rated health across life stages”. Population Health, 12: p. 1-7.
[50]	Shields, M, “Community belonging and self-perceived health. Health Reports, 19(2): p.51-60, 2008.
[51]	Richard, A., Rohrmann, S., Vandeleur, C. L., Schmid, M., Barth, J., and Eichholzer, M, “Loneliness is adversely associated with physical and mental health and lifestyle factors: Results from a Swiss national survey”. PLos ONE, 12(7): e0181442, 2017.
[52]	Luanaigh, C. and Lawlor, B.A, “Loneliness and the health of older people”. International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 23(12): p.1213-122, 2008.
[53]	McLaren, S., Gomez, R., Gill, P., and Chesler, J, “Marital status and suicidal ideation among Australian older adults: the mediating role of sense of belonging”. International Psychogeriatrics, 27(1): p.145-154, 2015.
[54]	Sum,S., Mathews,R,B., Pourghasem,M., and Hughes, I, “Internet use as a predictor of sense of community in older people”. CyberPsychology & Behavior, 12(2): p.235-239, 2009.
[55]	Lee, R. M., and Robbins, S. B, “The relationship between social connectedness and anxiety, self-esteem, and social identity”. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 45(3): p. 338–345, 1998.
[56]	Bailey, M., and McLaren, S, “Physical activity alone and with others as predictors of sense of belonging and mental health in retirees”. Aging & Mental Health, 9(1): p.82–90, 2005.
[57]	Sargent, J., Williams, R. A., Hagerty, B., Lynch-Sauer, J., and Hoyle, K, “Sense of belonging as a buffer against depressive symptoms”. Journal of the American Psychiatric Nurses Association, 8(4): p.120- 129, 2002.
[58]	Kissane, M., and McLaren, S, “Sense of belonging as a predictor of reasons for living in older adults”. Death Study, 30(3): p. 243-58, 2006.
[59]	Hamwey M, Norman C, Suss R, et al., “The state of mental health of New Yorkers”. New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. May, 2024.
[60]	Torres, S. “For a younger crowd”: Place, belonging, and exclusion among older adults facing neighborhood change”. Qualitative Sociology, 43: p. 1–20, 2020.
[61]	Ratnayake, M., Lukas, S., Brathwaite, S., Neave, J., and Henry, H. “Aging in place: Are we prepared?”. Delaware Journal of Public Health, 8(3): p. 28–31, 2022.
[62]	Smith, J, “Exploring the determinants and mitigating factors of loneliness among older adults”. Journal of Aging Studies, 45(2): p.123-135, 2023.
[63]	Inoue, Y., Wann, D. L., Lock, D., Sato, M., Moore, C., and Funk, D. C, “Enhancing older adults’ sense of belonging and subjective well-being through sport game attendance, team identification, and emotional support”. Journal of Aging and Health, 32(7-8): p.530-542, 2020.
[64]	Suragarn, U., Hain, D., and Pfaff, G, “Approaches to enhance social connection in older adults: An integrative review of literature”. Aging and Health Research, 1(3): 100029, 2021.
[65]	Broadbent, E., Loveys, K., Ilan, G., Chen, G., Chilukuri, M. M., Boardman, S. G., Doraiswamy, P. M., and Skuler, D, E, “An AI-Driven Social Robot to Alleviate Loneliness: Progress and Lessons Learned”. JAR Life, 13: p. 22–28, 2024.
[66]	Eubank, J.M., Oberlin, D.J., Alto, A., Sahyoun, N.R., Asongwed, E., Monroe-Lord, L., and Harrison, E.A. “Effects of lifestyle factors on cognition in minority population of older adults: A review”. Frontiers in Nutrition, 9: 841070, 2022.