Are Psychiatric Nurses More Vulnerable to Domestic Violence Compared with Nurses from Other Specialties?

Evon S. Shokre^1, and Nagwa A. Souilm²

¹Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, Faculty of Nursing, Fayoum University, Egypt

²Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, Faculty of Nursing, South Valley University, Egypt

Cite this paper:
Evon S. Shokre and Nagwa A. Souilm. Are Psychiatric Nurses More Vulnerable to Domestic Violence Compared with Nurses from Other Specialties?. American Journal of Nursing Research. 2017; 5(6):226-234. doi: 10.12691/ajnr-5-6-5

Abstract

Women, especially working women, suffer from domestic or intimate partner violence worldwide. Nurses are no exception. The study aim was to compare the magnitude of domestic violence and its effects among psychiatry nurses compared with nurses from other specialties. This cross-sectional comparative study was conducted on 120 psychiatric nurses from in Abbasiya Mental Hospital and 120 nurses in other specialties from El-zaitoon hospital. Data were collected using a self-administered questionnaire with the HITS (Hurt, Insult, Threaten, Scream) Scale for exposure to domestic violence, and the Women’s Experience with Battering (WEB) scale to assess the meanings women attribute to their exposure to domestic violence. The fieldwork lasted from April to June 2017. The nurses in the two groups had comparable demographic characteristics. More nurses in the psychiatry group were not sharing in home expenses (p=0.01), had independent house (p<0.001), had their work affecting home needs (p=0.03), and marital relations (p=0.04), and were asked to leave work by husband (p=0.03). The psychiatry nurses had significantly lower mean and median HITS scores (p=0.007). More psychiatry nurses reported thinking of leaving work as a consequence of domestic violence (p=0.001). In multivariate analysis, the independent positive predictors of the HITS score were the nurse age at marriage, husband age, sharing in home expenses, working overtime, and the work having a negative effect on marital life, while, the negative predictors were being a psychiatric nurse, age, and living in an independent house. For the effects score, the independent positive predictors were being a psychiatric nurse, having children, work having a negative effect on marital life, in addition to the HITS score, whereas the negative predictors were the income and working for need. In conclusion, the psychiatric nurses are less vulnerable to domestic violence, compared with other specialties; however, the impact of this violence is more severe among them, with a higher tendency to leave the work for this. The work environment, particularly in psychiatry should be improved with more flexible schedules and less hours of overtime work. More intervention research is suggested to assess the effectiveness of various approaches to deal with domestic violence.

Keywords:
psychiatric nurses domestic violence intimate partner violence

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References:

[1]	Dicola D., and Spaar E. (2016). Intimate Partner Violence. Am Fam Physician. 94(8): 646-651.
[2]	Yoshikawa K., Agrawal N.R., Poudel K.C., and Jimba M. (2012). A lifetime experience of violence and adverse reproductive outcomes: Findings from population surveys in India. BioScience Trends.; 6(3):115-121.
[3]	WHO. (2013). Global and regional estimates of violence against women: Prevalence and health effects of intimate partner violence and non-partner sexual violence.
[4]	Al-Hawari H., and El-Banna A. (2017). A medicolegal study of domestic violence in south region of Jordan. Egypt J Forensic Sci.; 7(1):5.
[5]	Kundapur R., Shetty S.M., Kempaller V.J., Kumar A., and Anurupa M. (2017): Violence against Educated Women by Intimate Partners in Urban Karnataka, India. Indian J Community Med.; 42(3):147-150.
[6]	Maquibar A., Vives-Cases C., Hurtig AK5, and Goicolea I. (2017). Professionals' perception of intimate partner violence in young people: a qualitative study in northern Spain. Reprod Health.; 14(1): 86.
[7]	Khademloo M., Moonesi F.S., and Gholizade H. (2013): Health Care Violence and Abuse towards Nurses in Hospitals in North of Iran. Global Journal of Health Science.; 5(4):211-216.
[8]	Barnawi F.H. (2015). Prevalence and Risk Factors of Domestic Violence Against Women Attending a Primary Care Center in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. J Interpers Violence.
[9]	Trevillion K., Hughes B., Feder G., Borschmann R., Oram S., and Howard L.M. (2014). Disclosure of domestic violence in mental health settings: A qualitative meta-synthesis. International Review of Psychiatry (Abingdon, England).; 26(4): 430-444.
[10]	Kalokhe A., del Rio C., and Dunkle K. (2017): Domestic violence against women in India: A systematic review of a decade of quantitative studies. Global public health.; 12(4): 498-513.
[11]	Jahromi M.K., Jamali S., Koshkaki A.R., and Javadpour S. (2016). Prevalence and Risk Factors of Domestic Violence Against Women by Their Husbands in Iran. Global Journal of Health Science.; 8(5): 175-183.
[12]	Lehmann P., Simmons C.A., and Pillai V.K. (2012): The validation of the checklist of controlling behaviors (CCB): Assessing coercive control in abusive relationships. Violence Against Women. ; 18: 913-33.
[13]	Mishra A., Patne S., Tiwari R., Srivastava D.K., Gour N., and Bansal M. A (2014). Cross-sectional Study to Find out the Prevalence of Different Types of Domestic Violence in Gwalior City and to Identify the Various Risk and Protective Factors for Domestic Violence. Indian Journal of Community Medicine: Official Publication of Indian Association of Preventive & Social Medicine.; 39(1): 21-25.
[14]	Mahapatro M., Gupta R., and Gupta V. (2012). The Risk Factor of Domestic Violence in India. Indian Journal of Community Medicine: Official Publicat ion of Indian Association of Preventive & Social Medicine.; 37(3): 153-157.
[15]	Semahegn A., and Mengistie B. (2015). Domestic violence against women and associated factors in Ethiopia; systematic review. Reproductive Health.; 12: 78.
[16]	Oshio T., Inoue A., and Tsutsumi A. (2017). Examining the mediating effect of work-to-family conflict on the associations between job stressors and employee psychological distress: a prospective cohort study. BMJ Open.; 7(8): e015608.
[17]	Mache S., Bernburg M., Vitzthum K., Groneberg D.A., Klapp B.F., and Danzer G. (2015). Managing work–family conflict in the medical profession: working conditions and individual resources as related factors. BMJ Open.; 5(4):e006871.
[18]	Bagherzadeh R., Taghizadeh Z., Mohammadi E., Kazemnejad A., Pourreza A., and Ebadi A. (2016). Relationship of work-family conflict with burnout and marital satisfaction: cross-domain or source attribution relations? Health Promotion Perspectives.; 6(1): 31-36.
[19]	Kishi Y., Kurosawa H., Morimura H., Hatta K., and Thurber S. (2011). Attitudes of Japanese nursing personnel toward patients who have attempted suicide. Gen Hosp Psychiatry. 33(4): 393-397.
[20]	Yoshizawa K., Sugawara N., and Yasui-Furukori N. (2016). Relationship between occupational stress and depression among psychiatric nurses in Japan. Arch Environ Occup Health. 71(1): 10-15.
[21]	Sharma K.K., and Vatsa M. (2011). Domestic Violence against Nurses by their Marital Partners: A Facility-based Study at a Tertiary Care Hospital. Indian Journal of Community Medicine: Official Publication of Indian Association of Preventive & Social Medicine.; 36(3): 222-227.
[22]	Fisch G.S., Cohen I.L., Jenkins E.C., and Brown W.T. (1988). Screening developmentally disabled male populations for fragile X: The effect of sample size. Am. J. Med. Genet.; 30: 655-663.
[23]	Kevin M.S., James M.S., Xiao-Qiang L., Robert E. Z., and Amer S. (1998). HITS: A Short Domestic Violence Screening Tool for Use in a Family Practice Setting. Fam Med; 30(7):508-12.
[24]	Smith P.H., Earp J.A., and DeVellis R. (1995). Measuring battering: development of the Women's Experience with Battering (WEB) Scale. Women's Health (Hillsdale, N.J.; 1(4): 273-288.
[25]	Brown J.B., Lent B., Brett P.J., Sas G., and Pederson L.L. (1996). Development of the Woman Abuse Screening Tool for use in family practice. Fam Med.; 28(6): 422-8.
[26]	Stewart D.E., and Vigod S.N. (2017). Mental Health Aspects of Intimate Partner Violence. Psychiatr Clin North Am.; 40(2): 321-334.
[27]	Snyder B.L. (2016). Women's experience of being interviewed about abuse: a qualitative systematic review. J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs.; 23(9-10): 605-613.
[28]	Soleimani R., Ahmadi R., and Yosefnezhad A. (2017): Health consequences of intimate partner violence against married women: a population-based study in northern Iran. Psychol Health Med.; 22(7): 845-850.
[29]	Savage M., Scarduzio J., Lockwood Harris. and Carlyle K. (2017). A Mixed Method Study of Intimate Partner Violence: How Sex and Severity Impact Perpetrator Prior Involvement, Abnormality, and Responsibility. Violence Vict..
[30]	Alfredsson H., Ask K., and von Borgstede C. (2015). Beliefs about intimate partner violence: A survey of the Swedish general public. Scand J Psychol. 2015 Nov 6.
[31]	Silverman J.G., Balaiah D., Ritter J., Dasgupta A., Boyce S.C., Decker M.R., Naik D.D., Nair S., Saggurti N., and Raj A. (2016): Maternal morbidity associated with violence and maltreatment from husbands and in-laws: findings from Indian slum communities. Reprod Health.; 13: 109.
[32]	Tran T.D., Tran T., Wynter K., and Fisher J. (2012). Interactions among alcohol dependence, perinatal common mental disorders and violence in couples in rural Vietnam: A cross-sectional study using structural equation modeling.BMC Psychiatry. 12:148.
[33]	Decker M.R., Nair S., Saggurti N., Sabri B., Jethva M., and Raj A. (2013). Violence-related coping, help-seeking and health care-based intervention preferences among perinatal women in Mumbai, India. J Interpers Violence.; 28: 1924-47.
[34]	Tsai L.C. (2016). Household Financial Management and Women's Experiences of Intimate Partner Violence in the Philippines: A Study Using Propensity Score Methods. Violence Against Women.
[35]	Gokler M.E., Arslantas D., and Unsal A. (2014). Prevalence of domestic violence and associated factors among married women in a semi-rural area of western Turkey. Pak J Med Sci.; 30(5): 1088-93.
[36]	Boeckel M.G., Wagner A., and Grassi-Oliveira R. (2015). The Effects of Intimate Partner Violence Exposure on the Maternal Bond and PTSD Symptoms of Children. J Interpers Violence.
[37]	Pels T., van Rooij F.B., and Distelbrink M. (2015). The Impact of Intimate Partner Violence (IPV) on Parenting by Mothers Within an Ethnically Diverse Population in the Netherlands. J Fam Violence.; 30(8): 1055-1067. Epub 2015 Aug 28.
[38]	Okuda M., Olfson M., Wang S., Rubio J.M., Xu Y., and Blanco C. (2015). Correlates of intimate partner violence perpetration: results from a National Epidemiologic Survey. J Trauma Stress. 28(1):49-56.
[39]	Yan E., and Karatzias T. (2016). Childhood Abuse and Current Intimate Partner Violence: A Population Study in Hong Kong. J Interpers Violence.
[40]	Muthengi E., Gitau T., and Austrian K. (2016). Is Working Risky or Protective for Married Adolescent Girls in Urban Slums in Kenya? Understanding the Association between Working Status, Savings and Intimate-Partner Violence. PLoS One.; 11(5): e0155988.