Doctors' and Nurses' Perceptions of Barriers to Conducting Handover in Hospitals in the Czech Republic

Katarzyna Machaczek¹, Malcolm Whitfield¹, Karen Kilner^2, and Peter Allmark¹

¹Centre for Health and Social Care Research, Sheffield Hallam University, Sheffield, United Kingdom

²Centre for Regional, Economic and Social Research, Sheffield Hallam University, Sheffield, United Kingdom

Cite this paper:
Katarzyna Machaczek, Malcolm Whitfield, Karen Kilner and Peter Allmark. Doctors' and Nurses' Perceptions of Barriers to Conducting Handover in Hospitals in the Czech Republic. American Journal of Nursing Research. 2013; 1(1):1-9. doi: 10.12691/ajnr-1-1-1

Abstract

Background: Patient care is shared between clinicians, and the effectiveness of their collaboration and information exchange will often determine the safety and quality of care provided.Handover enables clinicians to exchange information aboutprovision of patient care. Handovers are complex, their level of standardisation varies across departments and hospitals and they are influenced by the work environment. If during handover information pertinent to a patient's care is not transferred between clinicians it may lead to adverse events, including death. Methods: This paper reports a study of doctors’ and nurses’ perceptions of barriers to conducting handover in hospitals in the Czech Republic.This was an exploratory study using a self-administered questionnaire survey. The questionnaire evaluated clinicians’ perceptions of barriers to handover, including individual performance-related, organisational and environmental factors. Results:The questionnaire was sent to clinicians in two hospitals in the Czech Republic. A total of 181 doctors and 118 nurses returned the questionnaire. They held similar perceptions as to the most common performance-related obstacles to handover: messy, illegible and out-of-date records; and handover between more senior/junior members of staff. Also, social relationships and hierarchy seemed to have a negative impact on handover. The environmental factors negatively influenced included:not enough time, poor workforce planning, busy periods in the department, and interruptions. Conclusions: Handover emerged as a complex process negatively influenced by the work environment and social relationships. Nursing handover emerged as being conducted in a more standardised manner than handover between doctors; however, standardisation did not enhance the quality of information conveyed.Improvements in handover practices require organisational changes such as a reduction in workload and training for staff in conducting handover.

Keywords:
communication barriers handover nurses doctors Czech Republic

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References:

[1]	Makary, M.A., Sexton, J.B., Freischlag, J.A., et al. "Operating room teamwork among physicians and nurses: teamwork in the eye of the beholder."Journal of the American College of Surgeons; 202 (5), 746-752. 2006.
[2]	Stiell, A., Forster, A.J.,Stiell, I.G. et al. "Prevalence of information gaps in the emergency department and the effect on patient outcomes."Canadian Medical Association Journal; 169(10), 31028.2003.
[3]	Risser, D.T., Rice, M.M., Salisbury, M.L., et al. "The potential for improved teamwork to reduce medical errors in the emergency department."Annals of Emergency Medicine; 34 (3), 373-383, 1999.
[4]	WHO Draft Guidelines for Adverse Event Reporting and Learning Systems, World Health Organisation, 2005.
[5]	The Joint Commission 2006 National Patient Safety Goals.
[6]	Wilson, R.M., Runciman, W.B., Gibberd, R.W., et al. "The Quality in Australian Health Care Study". The Medical Journal of Australia,163 (9), 458-471, 1995.
[7]	Patterson, E.S. & Wears, R.L. "Patient handoffs: standardized and reliable measurement tools remain elusive."Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety, 36 (2), 52-61, 2010.
[8]	Matic, J., Davidson, P. M., &Salamonson, Y. "Bringing patient safety to the forefront through structured computerisation during clinical handover."Journal of Clinical Nursing, 20(1-2), 184-189, 2011.
[9]	Stevens, D. "Handovers and debussy."Quality & Safety in Healthcare,17 (1), 2-3, 2008.
[10]	Vidyarthi, A.R., Auerbach, A.D., Wachter, R.M. et al. "The impact of duty hours on resident self reports of errors". Journal of General Internal Medicine, 22 (2), 205-209, 2007.
[11]	AHRQ Hospital survey on patient safety culture: comparative database report. 2008.
[12]	Bump, G.M., Jovin, F., Destefano, L., et al. "Resident sign-out and patient hand-offs: opportunities for improvement."Teaching and Learning in Medicine, 23 (2), 105-111, 2011.
[13]	(13) Arora, V., Kao, J., Lovinger, D., et al. "Medication discrepancies in resident sign-outs and their potential to harm."Journal of General Internal Medicine, 22 (12), 1751-1755, 2007.
[14]	Ye, K., McD Taylor, D., Knott, J.C., et al. "Handover in the emergency department: deficiencies and adverse effects", Emergency Medicine Australasia, 19 (5), 433-441, 2007.
[15]	Riesenberg, L.A., Leitzsch, J. & Little, B.W. "Systematic review of handoff mnemonics literature."American Journal of Medical Quality: The Official Journal of the American College of Medical Quality, 24 (3), 196-204, 2009.
[16]	Riesenberg, L.A., Leisch, J. & Cunningham, J.M. "Nursing handoffs: a systematic review of the literature."The American Journal of Nursing, 110 (4), 24-34, 2010.
[17]	Borowitz, S., Waggoner-Fountain, L., Bass, E. &Sledd, R. "Adequacy of information transferred at resident sign-out (inhospital handover of care): a prospective survey."Quality & Safety in Healthcare, 17 (1), 6-10, 2008.
[18]	Bruce, K. &Suserud, B.O. "The handover process and triage of ambulance-borne patients: the experiences of emergency nurses."Nursing in Critical Care, 10 (4), 201-209, 2005.
[19]	Sutcliffe, K.M., Lewton, E. & Rosenthal, M.M. "Communication failures: an insidious contributor to medical mishaps." Academic Medicine, 79 (2), 186-194, 2004.
[20]	Manias, E. & Street, A. "The handover: uncovering the hidden practices of nurses."Intensive & Critical Care Nursing, 16 (6), 373-383, 2000.
[21]	Sutcliffe, K.M., Lewton, E. & Rosenthal, M.M. "Communication failures: an insidious contributor to medical mishaps."Academic Medicine, 79 (2),186-194, 2004.
[22]	Landucci, D, and Gipe, B.T. "The art and science of the handoff. How hospitalists share data."Cost Quality Quarterly Journal, 4 (3), 8-10, 1998.
[23]	Mintzberg, H. "The strategy process: concepts, contexts, cases."2nd edn.Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 1991.
[24]	Manias, E. & Street, A. "The handover: uncovering the hidden practices of nurses."Intensive & Critical Care Nursing, 16 (6), 373-383, 2000.
[25]	Payne, S., Hardey, M. & Coleman, P. "Interactions between nurses during handovers in elderly care."Journal of Advanced Nursing,32 (2),277-285, 2000.
[26]	Dracup, K. & Morris, P.E. "Passing the torch: The challenge of handoffs."American Journal of Critical Care, 7 (2),95-97, 2008.
[27]	Solet, D.J., Norvell, J.M., Rutan, G.H. et al. "Lost in translation: challenges and opportunities in physician-to-physician communication during patient handoffs."Academic Medicine, 80 (12), 1094-1099, 2005.
[28]	Riesenberg, L.A., Leisch, J. & Cunningham, J.M. "Nursing handoffs: a systematic review of the literature."The American Journal of Nursing, 110 (4), 24-34, 2010.
[29]	Jauhar, S. "Patient handoffs, or walking along a narrow mountain ledge."Medscape Journal of Medicine, 10 (3), 57-57, 2008.
[30]	Luo, J., Hales, R., Hilty, D. & Brennan, C. "Clinical computing: electronic sign-out using a personal digital assistant."Psychiatric Services, 52 (2), 173-174, 2001.
[31]	Riesenberg, L.A., Leitzsch, J. & Little, B.W. "Systematic review of handoff mnemonics literature."American Journal of Medical Quality: The Official Journal of the American College of Medical Quality 2009, 24 (3), 196-204.
[32]	Borowitz, S., Waggoner-Fountain, L., Bass, E. &Sledd, R. Adequacy of information transferred at resident sign-out (inhospital handover of care): a prospective survey. Quality & Safety in Healthcare 2008,(17), 1:6-10.
[33]	Pezzolesi, C., Schifano, F., Pickles, J., et al. Clinical handover incident reporting in one UK general hospital. International Journal for Quality in Health Care: Journal of the International Society for Quality in Health Care / ISQua, 22 (5), 396-401, 2010.
[34]	Bomba, D.T. &Prakash, R. A description of handover processes in an Australian public hospital. Australian Health Review: A Publication of the Australian Hospital Association, 29 (1), 68-79, 2005.
[35]	Elash, A. With salaries on par with those of secretaries, Czech MDs prepare for strike. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 161(2): 185, 1999.
[36]	Riesenberg, L.A., Leitzsch, J. & Little, B.W. Systematic review of handoff mnemonics literature. American Journal of Medical Quality: The Official Journal of the American College of Medical Quality, 24 (3), 196-204, 2009.
[37]	Nagpal, K., Arora, S., Abboudi, M., Vats, A., Wong, H., Manchanda, C., Vincent, C. &Moorthy, K. Postoperative handover problems, pitfalls, and prevention of error. Annals of Surgery, 252 (1), 171-176, 2010.
[38]	Khatri N, Brown GD, Hicks LL.From a blame culture to a just culture in health care.Health Care Manage Review, 34:312-322, 2009.
[39]	Allen, I.E. and Seaman, C.A.Likert Scales and Data Analyses.Quality Progress, 40 (7), 64-65, 2007.
[40]	Wilson, E.B. Probable inference, the law of succession, and statistical inference. Journal of the American Statistical Association,22, 209-212, 1927.
[41]	Bergman, M.M., Textual and Audiovisual Analyses Within a Mixed Methods Framework. in SAGE Handbook of Mixed Methods in Social & Behavioural Research, SAGE Publication, Thousand Oaks, 2010, 379-396.
[42]	Petersen, L,A., Orav, E.J., Teich, J.M. et al. "Using a computerized sign-out program to improve continuity of inpatient care and prevent adverse events."Joint Commission Journal on Quality Improvement, 24 (2), 77-87, 1998.
[43]	Behara, R., Wears, R.L., Perry, S.J., "A conceptual framework for studying the safety of transitions in Emergency Care." Advances in Patient Safety: From Research to Implementation (Volume 2: Concepts and Methodology). Rockville (MD): Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (US), Feb. 2005
[44]	Ekman, I., Segesten, K. "Deputed power of medical control: the hidden message in the ritual of oral shift reports."Journal of Advanced Nursing, 22, 1006-1011, 1995.
[45]	Ye, K., McD Taylor, D., Knott, J.C., et al. "Handover in the emergency department: deficiencies and adverse effects", Emergency Medicine Australasia, 19 (5), 433-441, 2007.
[46]	Kerr, M.P. "A qualitative study of shift handover practice and function from a socio‐technical perspective." Journal of Advanced Nursing, 37 (2), 125-134, 2002.
[47]	Milanovich, D.M., Driskell, J.E., Stout, R.J. et al. "Status and cockpit dynamics: a review and empirical study."Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice, 2 (3),155-167, 1998.
[48]	Sexton, J.B., Thomas, E.J. &Helmreich, R.L. "Error, stress, and teamwork in medicine and aviation: cross sectional surveys." British Medical Journal, 320 (7237), 745-749, 2000.
[49]	Kerr, M.P. "A qualitative study of shift handover practice and function from a socio‐technical perspective."Journal of Advanced Nursing, 37 (2), 125-134, 2002.
[50]	Apker, J., Mallak, L.A., Gibson, S.C. Communicating in the Gray Zone: Perceptions about Emergency Physicianhospitalist Handoffs and Patient Safety. Academic Emergency Medicine, 14 (10), 884 - 894, 2007.