Journals A-Z
All Subjects
Free Journals
sciepub.com
American Journal of Mechanical Engineering
ISSN (Print): 2328-4102 ISSN (Online): 2328-4110 Website: https://www.sciepub.com/journal/ajme Editor-in-chief: Kambiz Ebrahimi, Dr. SRINIVASA VENKATESHAPPA CHIKKOL
Open Access
Journal Browser
Go
Issue 1, Volume 7
Article Metrics
  • 11385
    Views
  • 10599
    Saves
  • 0
    Citations
  • 1
    Likes
Export Article
American Journal of Mechanical Engineering. 2019, 7(1), 20-34
DOI: 10.12691/ajme-7-1-3
Open AccessSpecial Issue

Enhancement Heat Transfer in a Tube Fitted with Passive Technique as Twisted Tape Insert - A Comprehensive Review

Ahmed Hashim Yousif1, and Maher Rehaif Khudhair1

1AL-Dewaniyah Technical Institute, AL-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University, Iraq

Pub. Date: February 14, 2019
View Full Text Full Text PDF Full Text ePUB

Cite this paper:
Ahmed Hashim Yousif and Maher Rehaif Khudhair. Enhancement Heat Transfer in a Tube Fitted with Passive Technique as Twisted Tape Insert - A Comprehensive Review. American Journal of Mechanical Engineering. 2019; 7(1):20-34. doi: 10.12691/ajme-7-1-3

Abstract

The process of improving heat transfer is one of the important topics that are constantly studied. There are three techniques to improve the heat transfer (passive, active and compound). Most studies are done using the passive technique because it does not need external energy. its work is only to mix the flow to control the growth of the boundary layer and to increase the thermal exchange between the wall and the fluid flow by placing the techniques inside the flow. In this study, emphasis was placed on the studies and research carried out on the first technique (passive technique) and put in a table according to the years of publication as a reference for the students studying in this subject and for heat exchangers designers who aim to reduce weight and cost in the process of manufacturing heat exchangers for reduce their effort and time to reach the optimal design and get the best results.

Keywords:
heat transfer twisted tape insert heat exchanger enhancement

Creative CommonsThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References:

[1]  A. Dewan, P. Mahanta, K. Sumithra Raju and P. Suresh Kumar (2004) “Review of passive hyeat transfer augmentation technique “ Proc. Instn. Engrs. Vol.218 Part A P.P 509-527.
 
[2]  S. S. Joshi and V. M. Kriplani (2011). “review of heat transfer augmentation with tape inserts “international journal of engineering science and technology Vol. 3 P.P 1944-1947.
 
[3]  Chintan, Prajapati, Mrs. Pragan, Patel, Mr. Jatin, Patel and Umang Patel (2012). “a review of heat transfer enhancement using twisted tape”. international journal of advance engineering research and studies. Vol.11, Issue 1, P.P 162-124.
 
[4]  Amar Subhash Mohite, Navnath Sawant, Siddharth Chougale, Dashmeet Obreoi and prof. Avinash Dararkar (2016). “review on heat transfer enhancement using inserts” international journal of information technology and mechanical engineering. Vol. 2, Issue 3. P.P 8-11.
 
[5]  Kumbhar, D. G. and Dr. Sane,N.K. (2010) “heat transfer enhancement in circular tube twisted with swirl generator: A Review “3rd international conference on advances mechanical engineering January 4-6. P.P 188-192.
 
[6]  C.K. Pardhi, Dr. Alka Bani Agrawal and Dr. Prashant Baredar (2013) “recent advance in heat transfer augmentation by using twisted taps: A review “innovative system design and engineering. Vol. 4 No. 6. PP 13-21.
 
[7]  Tuqa Abdulrazzaq, Hussein Togun, M. K. A. Ariffin, A. Badarudin N. M. Adam, S. Masori and E Sadeghenizhad (2013) “enhancement of heat transfer nanofluid flow in circular pipe with twisted tapes inserts: review”. Australian journal of basic and applied science. Vol.7, No. 9. PP97-102.
 
[8]  Suhas V. Patil and P. V. Vijay Babu (2011). “heat transfer augmentation in a circular tube and square duct with swirl flow generators: A review “ international journal of chemical engineering and application. Vol. 2, No. 5, PP 326-331.
 
[9]  Amol, P. Yadav, Pranit, M. Patil and Ddr. P. A. Patil (2014) “the effect of insertion of different geometries on heat transfer performance in circular Pipe: A review” international journal of modern engineering research Vol. 4 Issue. 11 P.P 47-53.
 
[10]  Laith J. Habeeb, Fouad, A. Saleh, Bassim, M. Majeel (2015) “heat transfer enhancement in cirdurar tube with passive technique as twisted tape insert in turbulent flow regime: A review of the recent literature “AASCIT journal of nanoscience Vol. 1, No. 4 P.P 43-49.
 
[11]  Mukesh, P. Mangtani and K. M. Watt (2015). “effect of twisted tape inserts on heat transfer in tube – A review”. Int, J, Mech. And Reb. Res. Vol, 4, No. 2 P.P 97-104.
 
[12]  Amit, Rajotiya, Yogesh, Sharma, Sunil, Dhingra and Gurjeet, Singh. (2015). “review of enhancement of heat transfer rate by using inserts in flow channel “IJIRST Vol. 2, Issue. 2. PP. 21-24.
 
[13]  Anial Yadav. (2009). “effect of half-length twisted tape turbulator on heat transfer and pressure drop characteristic inside a double pipe U-bend, heat exchanger” Jordan journal of mech. and industrial engg. Vol. 3, No. 1, PP. 17-22.
 
[14]  Pravin S. Nikam, Prof. R. Y. Patil, prof. P. R. Patil, prof. P. N. Borse (2016) “heat transfer enhancement technique with inserts different geometries – A Review “international journal of engineering and techniques Vol. 2, Issue. 3 P.P 123-127.
 
[15]  P. Dipak and R, Y, Patil. (2017). “Passive heat transfer augmentation methods in circular tube: A review”. international journal of innovative research science, engineering and technology. Vol, 6 Issue.1 P.P 512-526.
 
[16]  Divyesh Prafulla Ubale (2017) “heat transfer enhancement in heat exchanger using twisted tape inserts: A review” international conference on ideas, impact and innovation in mechanical engineering. Vol. 5 Issue. 6 pp425-428.
 
[17]  Nimish Dubey and Mr. Morrish Kumar. (2017). “design modification in heat exchanger twisted tape for heat transfer enhancement: A review “international journal of engineering sciences and research technology Vol. 6 No. 7 PP 1-5.
 
[18]  Kreith, F and Margolis, D (1959). “heat transfer and friction in turbulent vortex flow” Appl. Sci. Res.Vpl. 8 PP457-473.
 
[19]  Symour, E. V. A. (1963) “a note of improvement in performance obtain from fitting twisted tape turbulence promotes to tubular heat exchanger” JICHE Vol. 41 PP159-162.
 
[20]  Gampll, W. and Bundy, R. D. (1963) “high flux heat transfer characteristic in turbulent swirl flow subjected to large transverse temperature gradient” AICHE Vol. 9 PP 55-59.
 
[21]  Smithberg, E. and Lands, F. (1964) “friction and force convection heat transfer characteristic in tube with twisted tape” Trans. ASME, J. Heat Transfer Vol. 86, PP 39-49.
 
[22]  Novozhilov, J. F. and Migai, V. K. (1964). “intensifying convection heat transfer within tube by means of induced roughness”. Teploenergetike, Vol. 11, No. 9, PP 60-63.
 
[23]  Kreith, F and Sonju, O.K. (1965). “the decay of turbulent swirl flow in pipe”. J. fluid mechanic Vol. 22, PP 257-271.
 
[24]  Thorsen, R. and Landis, F. (1968) “friction and heat transfer characteristic in tubular swirl flow subject to large transverse temperature gradient “ Trans. ASME J. heat transfer, Vol. 90. PP 87-97.
 
[25]  Lopina, R. F. and Bergles, A. F. (1969) “heat transfer and pressure drop in tape generated swirl flow of single phase water “Trans. ASME J. heat transfer Vol. 91, PP 434-441.
 
[26]  Kidd Jr, G. G. (1969). “heat transfer and pressure drop for nitrogen flowing in tube containing twisted tape” AICHE, J. Vol. 15, PP 581-585.
 
[27]  Backshall, R. G. and Landies, F. (1969). “boundary layer velocity distribution in turbulent swirl pipe flow” Trans. ASME Basic engng. Vol. 91, PP. 728-733.
 
[28]  Kumar, P. and Jadd, R. L. (1970) “heat transfer with coil wire turbulence promotes” Canadian J. Chme. Engeg. Vol. 48, PP 378-383.
 
[29]  Blackwelder, R. and Kreith, F. (1970) “experimental investigation of heat transfer and pressure drop in decaying swiral flow “Trans. ASME augmentation of convective heat and mass transfer. PP 102-108.
 
[30]  Dare, A. W. and Singham, J. R. (1972). “numerical production of friction and heat transfer characteristic of fully developed laminar flow in tube contain twisted tapes “ Trans. ASME J. heat transfer, Vol. 17, PP 72-85.
 
[31]  Klepper, O. H. (1972). “heat transfer performance of short twisted tapes”. AICHE J. Vpl.35, PP 1-24.
 
[32]  Date, A. W. (1973). “flow in tube contain twisted tapes” heat and vent. Engr. J. environ. Sic. Vol. 47, PP 240-249.
 
[33]  Date, A. W. (1974). “production of fully develop flow in tube contain twisted tapes “Int. J. heat and mass transfer Vol. 17, PP 845-859.
 
[34]  Zozulya, N. V. and Shkoratov, I. Y. (1974). “effect of length of twisted tape turbulence promoter and its initial twisting pitch of augmentation of heat transfer inside a tube “heat transfer Sov. Res. Vol. 6, PP 98-100.
 
[35]  Hang, S. W. Bergles, A. E. (1976). “augmentation of laminar flow heat transfer in tubes by means of twisted tap inserts “ASME J. heat transfer Vol. 98 PP 251-256.
 
[36]  Huang, F. and Tson, F. K. (1979). “friction and heat transfer in turbulence free swirl flow in pipe ‘Trans. ASME J. heat transfer Vol. 39, PP 1-9.
 
[37]  Kumar, R. and Bharadwaj, R.K. (1979). “heat transfer and pressure drop in decaying swirl flow of water through a tube contain the twisted tap“. J. Jnst. Engrs. (India). Vol. 60, PP 72-77.
 
[38]  Fillipak, E. (1980). “heat transfer in vertical tube with twisted tape swirl generator” Zeszyty Naukowe Politechniki Lodzkiej Mecanical Vol. 60, PP41-53.
 
[39]  Donevski, B. and Kulesza, J. (1980) “friction diring isothermal flow in tube with twisted tape” Zeszyty Naukowe Politechniki Lodzkiej Mecanical Vol. 58, PP 5-25.
 
[40]  Rao, K. S. (1983). “augmentation of heat transfer in the axial ducts of electrical machines with tape generated swirl flow” IEEE trans. Power appar syst, Vol. 102, PP 2750-2756.
 
[41]  Watanable, K. Taira, T. and Mori, Y. (1983). “heat transfer augmentation in turbulent flow by twisted tape at high temperature and optimum performance” heat transfer Jap. Res. Vol. 12, PP 1-31.
 
[42]  Yamada, Y., Akai, M. and Mori, Y. (1984) shell and tube side heat transfer augmentation by the use of the wall radiation in cross flow shell and tube heat exchanger” Trans. ASME J.heat transfer. Vol. 106, PP 735-742.
 
[43]  Budov, V. M., Zamyatin, S. A. and Farafonov, V. A. (1985) “distribution of velocity and pressure in cylindrical channel with flow swirled by local twisted tape swirl” Thermal engn. Vol. 32, PP 520-521.
 
[44]  Algifri, A.H. and Bharadwaj, R, K. (1985). “production heat transfer for decaying turbulent swirl flow in pipe”. Int. J. heat and mass transfer Vol. 28, PP 1635-1643.
 
[45]  Beckermann, C. and Goldschmind, V. W. (1986). “heat transfer augmentation in fuel – way of a water heater” ASHRAE trans. Vol. 92, PP 485-495.
 
[46]  Fomino, V. N., Fedorov, I. I.,Titova, E. Y., Martynychev, M. I. and Romanov, A. I. (1987). “thermal efficiency and operational reliability of finned tube economizers of p-57-2M boiler”. Thrmal. Engng. Vol. 34, PP 250-253.
 
[47]  Genis, G. I. and Rautennbach, W. L. (1987). “high heat flux force convection heat transfer in tubes with twisted tape inserts” Trans. ASME J. heat transfer Vol. 68, PP 1-9.
 
[48]  Algifri, A.H., Bharadwaj, R, K. and Rao, Y. V. N. (1988). “heat transfer in turbulent decaying swirl flow in circular pipe” Int. J. heat and mass transfer Vol. 31, PP 1563-1568.
 
[49]  Gupte, N. S. and Date, A. W. (1989). “friction and heat transfer characteristic of helical turbulent air flow of annuli” Trans. ASME J. heat transfer Vol. 111, PP 337-344.
 
[50]  Peterson, S. C., France, D. M., and Carlson, R, D, (1989) “experiments in high pressure turbulent swirl flow” Trans. ASME J. heat transfer Vol. 108, PP215-218.
 
[51]  Saha, S. K., Gaitonde, U. N. and Date, A. W. (1990). “heat transfer and pressure drop characteristic of turbulent flow in circular tube fitted with regularly spaced twisted tape elements” Expl. Thermal and fluid Sci. Vol. 3, PP 632-640.
 
[52]  Oliver, D, R, and Shoji, Y, (1992). “heat transfer enhancement in a round tube using different tube inserts” non-Newtonian fluid J. Cham. Engng. Res. And Det. Vol. 70, PP 558-564.
 
[53]  Manglik, R. K. and Bergles, A. E. (1993). “heat transfer and pressure drop correlation for twisted tape insert of isothermal tube part II: Transition and turbulent flow” Trans. ASME J. heat transfer Vol. 115, PP 771-780.
 
[54]  Afanasyer, V. N., Chudunovsky, Y. P., Leontive, A. I. and Roganov, P. S. (1993) “ turbulent flow friction and heat transfer characteristic for spherical cavities on a flat plat” Expl. Thermal fluid Sci. Vol. 7, PP 1-2.
 
[55]  Arici, M. E. and Asan, H. (1994) “enhancement of turbulent flow heat transfer in tubes by means of wire coil inserts” ASME PD Adv. In heat transfer Vol.64, PP 113-117.
 
[56]  Fann, S. Yang, W. J. and Zhang, N. (1994). “local heat transfer in rotating serpentine passage with rib-roughened surfaces” Int. J, heat and mass transfer Vol. 37, PP 217-228.
 
[57]  Hijikata, K., Nagasaki, T. and Minami, K. (1994) “study of heat transfer augmentation in high temperature field by a radiation promoted generated a secondary flow” Int. J. Exp. Thermal and fluid Sci. Vol. 7, PP 31-42.
 
[58]  Naumov V. K. and Semashko N.N. (1994). “analytical model of estimating thermos-physical and strength parameters of cold pipe with the twisted tape under symmetric heating by pules of external heat flux” Plasma Devices and Ops. Vol. 3, PP 267-268.
 
[59]  Naumov, V. K., Semashko, N. N. and Komov, A. T. (1995). “finite deferent approximation of the adiabatic cross suction technique in a numerical analysis of a single side heating process of a cooled pipe with twisted tapes inside by external heat flux pules” plasma device and ops. Vol. 4, PP 141-142.
 
[60]  Fujita, Y. and Lopes, A. M. (1995). “heat transfer enhancement of twisted tape inserts in turbulent pipe flow”. heat transfer jop, res. Vol. 24, PP 378-398.
 
[61]  Naumov, V. K., Semashko, N. N. and Komov, A. T. (1995). “modification of adiabatic cross suction technique for calculation pipe containing twisted tapes under symmetric heating by external stationary heat flux with a high power density”. Plasma Device and ops. Vol. 5, PP 43-58.
 
[62]  Rau, M. M. and Sastri, V. M. (1995) “experimental investigation of fluid flow and heat transfer in rotation tube twisted tape inserts” Int, J. heat and mass transfer Vol. 16, PP 19-28.
 
[63]  Ravigururasjan, T. S, andBergles, A. E. (1996) “development and verification of general correlation for pressure drop and heat transfer in single phase turbulent flow in enhanced tube” Exp. Thermal and fluid sci. Vol. 13, PP 55-70.
 
[64]  Taslim, M. E., Li, T. and Kercher, D. M. (1996) “experimental heat transfer and friction in channeled roughned with angle v-shaped and discrete ribs on two opposite walls” Trans. ASME J. turbomach. Vol. 118, PP 20-28.
 
[65]  Al-Fahed, S. and Chakroun, W. (1996) “effect of tube tape clearance on heat transfer for fully developed turbulent flow in a horizontal isothermal tube” Int. J. heat and fluid flow. Vol. 17, PP 173-178.
 
[66]  Agarwal, S. F. and Raja Rao, M. (1996) “heat transfer augmentation for flow of viscous liquid in circular tubes using twisted tape inserts”. Int. J. heat and mass transfer Vol. 99, PP 3547-3557.
 
[67]  Klaczak, A. (1996). “heat transfer and pressure drop in tube with short tabulators” Wsrme and Stoffebetragung, Vol. 31, PP 399-401.
 
[68]  Lokanath, M. S. (1997) “performance evaluation of full length and half-length twisted tape inserts on laminar flow heat transfer in tube in proceeding og 3rd” ISHNT-ASME heat and mass transfer conference India, PP 319-324.
 
[69]  Saha, S. K. and Sunden, B. (1997). “heat transfer and pressure drop characteristics of laminar flow through a circular tube fitted with regularly spaced twisted tape elements with multiple twists”. In proceeding of 3rd ISHMT-ASME heat and mass transfer conference India, PP 313-318.
 
[70]  Liao, Q. and Xin, M. D. (2000) “Augmentation of convection heat transfer insides tubes with three dimensional internal extended surfaces and twisted tap inserts” Chem. Eng. J. Vol. 12, PP 95-105.
 
[71]  Kumar, A and Prasad, B. N. (2000) “investigation of twisted tape inserted solar water heater heat transfer, friction factor and thermal performance results” Renewable energy Vol. 19, p.p 379-398.
 
[72]  Yakoya, S., Takagi, S., Lguchi, M., Murkawa, K., Yasugaira, W. and Hara, S. (2000). “development of swirling flow generator in immersing nozzle” ISIJ. Int. Vol. 40, P.P 584-588.
 
[73]  Klaczak, A. (2000). “heat transfer by laminar flow in vertical pipe with twisted tape insert”. heat and mass transfer Vol. 36, P.P 195-199.
 
[74]  Saha, S.K. and Dutta, A. (2001) “thermos-hydraulic study of laminar swirl flow throw a circular tube fitted with twisted tapes” Trans. ASME J. heat transfer Vol. 123, P.P 417-421.
 
[75]  Inaba, H. and Ozaki, K. (2001) “heat transfer enhancement and flow drug reduction of force convection in circular tube by means of wire coil insert” In Handbook of compact heat transfer exchanger (Eds. R. K. Saha, K. J. Bell, S. Mochiizuki, and V.V. Wasdekar) P.P 445-452.
 
[76]  Kim, H. Y., Koyama, S. and Matsumoto, W. (2001). “flow pattern and flow characteristicfor counter current tow phase flow in a vertical round tube with wire coil insert” Int. J. multiphase flow Vol. 27, P.P 2063-2081.
 
[77]  Rahai, H. R., Vu, H. T. and Sojaaeefard, M. H. (2001) “mixing enhancement using a coil insert” Appl. Thermal engng. Vol. 21, P.P 303-309.
 
[78]  Mahmood, G. I., Hill, M. L., Nelson, D. L., Ligrani, P. M.,Moon, H. K. and Glezer, B. (2001). “local heat transfer and flow structure on the above a dimpled surface in channel” Trans. ASME J. Turbomach., Vol. 123, P.P 115.
 
[79]  Chen, J. Steinhagen, H. M. and Duffy, M. (2001) “heat transfer enhancement in dimpled tube” Appl. Thermal engeg. Vol. 21, P.P 535-547.
 
[80]  Saha, S. K., Dutta, A. and Dhal, S. K. (2001). “friction and heat transfer characteristic of laminar swirl flow through a circular tube fitted with regularly spaced twisted tape element” Int. J. of heat and mass transfer Vol. 44, P.P 4211-4223.
 
[81]  Rahai, H. R. and Wang, T. W. (2002) “Velocity field characteristic of turbulent jets from round tubes with coil insert” Appl. Thermal engeg. Vol. 22, P.P 6063-6081.
 
[82]  Chang, S. W. (2002). “forced heat convection in a reciprocating duct fifing with 45 degree crossed ribs” Int. J. thermal Sci. Vol. 41, P.P 229-240.
 
[83]  Mahmood, G. L., Lingrani, P. M. (2002). “heat transfer in dimpled channel combined influence of aspect ratio temperature ratio, Raynold number and flow structure” Int. J. heat and mass transfer. Vol. 45, P.P 2011-2020.
 
[84]  Liu, T., Sun, X. and Wang, H. (2002) “Neural network analysis of boiling heat transfer enhancement using additives.” Int. J. heat and mass transfer Vol. 45, P.P 5083-5089.
 
[85]  Golriz, M.R. and Grace, J. R. (2002). “augmentation of heat transfer by deflector on circulating fluidized bed membrane walls”. Int. J. heat and mass transfer Vol. 45, P.P 1149-1154.
 
[86]  Kulankura, S. and Herold, K. E. (2002) “surface tension of aqueous lithium bromide with heat\mass transfer enhancement additives”. Vol.25, P.P 383-389.
 
[87]  Lokanath, M. S. and Misal, R. D. (2002). “ An experimental study on the performance of plate heat exchanger and an augmented shell and tube heat exchanger for different types of fluids for marine applications”. In Proceedings of 5th ISHMT– ASME Heat and Mass Transfer Conference, India, pp. 863-868 (Tata McGraw-Hill, New Delhi).
 
[88]  Wank, L. and Sunden, B. (2002) “performance comparison of sum tube insert” Int. commun. Heat transfer Vol. 29, P.P 45-56.
 
[89]  Inaba, H. and Haruki, N. (2002) “heat transfer enhancement of water flow in a straight tube insert” Tran. Jap. Soc. Mech. Engre. Part B Vol. 68, P.P 481-488.
 
[90]  Ujhidy, A., Nemeth, J and Szepvolgyi, J. (2003). “fluid flow in tubes with helical element” Chem. Engeg. And Processing Vol. 42, P.P 1-7.
 
[91]  Suresh, Kumar, P., Mahanta, P. and Dewan, A. (2003) “study of laminar flow in large diameter annulus with twisted tape insert” In proceeding of 2nd international conference on heat transfer, fluid mechanics and thermodynamic, Victoria fall, Zambia. Paper KP3.
 
[92]  Yang, Y. T. and Hwang, C. Z. (2003). “calculation of turbulent flow and heat transfer in a porous – baffled channel” Int. J. heat and mass transfer Vol. 46., P.P 771-780.
 
[93]  Ray, S. and Date, A. W. (2003) “friction and heat transfer characteristic of flow through square duct with twisted tape insert” Int. J. heat and mass transfer Vol.46, P.P 889-902.
 
[94]  Suresh, Kumar, P., Mahanta, P. and Dewan, A. (2004). “study the heat transfer and pressure drop in a large hydraulic diameter annulus” 17th national heat and mass transfer conference and 6th ISHMT/ASMEheat and mass transfer conference India Gandhi center for atomic research, Kalpakkam, India. P.P 62-66.
 
[95]  Eiamsa-ard, Smith, Chinaruk Thianpong and Pongjet P Promvonge (2006). “experimental investigation of heat transfers and flow friction in a circular tube fitted with regularly spaced twised tape elements” International communications in heat and mass transfer Vol. 33, P.P 1225-1233.
 
[96]  Paisam Naphon. (2006). “heat transfer and pressure drop in horizontal double pipes with and without twisted tape insert” international communication in heat and mass transfer. Vol. 33, No. 2, PP. 166-175.
 
[97]  Watcharin Noothong, Eiamsa-ard S. and Ponget Promonge (2006). “effect of twisted tape insert on heat transfer in a tube” the 2nd joint int. conference on sustainable energy and environment (SEE).
 
[98]  Honx Xianhe Deng, Koui Huang and Zhiwo Li. (2007). “compound heat transfer enhancement of convergent divergent tube with evenly spaced twisted tapes” Chinese journal of chemical engg. Vol. 15, No. 1. PP. 53-62.
 
[99]  Garc A., Solano J. P., Vicente P. G. and Viedma. (2007). “enhancement of laminar and transitional flow heat transfer in tube by means of wire coil insert” int. J of heat and mass transfer. Vol. 50, PP. 3167-3189.
 
[100]  Eiamsa-ard, Smith and P. Promvonge. (2007). “heat transfer behaviors in a tube with combined conical ring and twisted tape insert” International communications in heat and mass transfer. Vol. 15, No. 6, P.P 814-820.
 
[101]  Chang S. W., JYih Jena and Jin Shuen Liou (2007) “turbulent heat transfers and pressure drop in tube fitted with serrated twisted tape” International journal of thermal science Vol. 46, PP. 506-518.
 
[102]  Chang S. W., Tsun Lirng Yang and Jin Shuen Liou (2007) “heat transfer and pressure drop in tube with broken twisted tape insert”. experimental thermal and fluid scince Vol. 32, PP. 489-501.
 
[103]  Chang S. W., Tong-Miin Liou, Jin Shuen and Kun- Tse Chen (2008). “turbulent heat transfer in a tube fitted with serrated twisted tape under rolling and pitching environment with application to shipping” J. of Ocean eng. Vol. 35, PP. 1569-1577.
 
[104]  Ashis K. Mazumder, Sujoy K. Saha (2008). “enhancement of thermos hydrolic performance of turbulent flow in rectangular and square ribbed ducts with twisted tape insert”. Journal of heat transfer AUGUST Vol. 130.
 
[105]  Xie Pengcherg, Li Fengxiany, Diny Yumei, Yan Hue, Guan Chang Feny and Yang Weiminm (2008) “experimental study of heat transfer enhancement and friction losses induced by inserted rotary – assembly strand (I) water “Chinese Journal of chemical engineering Vol.16, No.6, PP 849-855.
 
[106]  Chinaruk T., Petpices E., Khwanchit W. and Eiasma S. (2009). “compound heat transfer enhancement of a dimple tube with twisted tape swirl generator”. Int. communication heat and mass transfer Vol. 36, PP. 698-704.
 
[107]  Eiamsa-ard, S., Ponjet Promvonge, Chinaruk T. and Eiamsa P. (2009) “convective heat transfer in circular tube with short length twisted tape” Int. communication in heat and mass transfer Vol. 36, PP. 356-371.
 
[108]  Jaisankar, T. K. Radhakrishnan, P.P. and Sheeba, K. N. (2009) “experimental studies on heat transfer and friction factor characteristic of thermosyphon solar water heater system fitted with spacer at the trailing edge of twisted tape” Applied thermal engineering Vol. 29, PP. 1224-1231.
 
[109]  Bharadwaj, A. D. Khondge and Date, A. W. (2009). “heat transfer and pressure drop in spirally grooved tube with twisted tape insert” J. heat transfer Vol. 52, No. 5, PP. 1938-1944.
 
[110]  Chang, S. W. Arther William Lees and Hsien-Tsung Chang (2009) “influence of spiky twisted tape insert on thermal fluid performance of tubular air-water bubbly flow”. international journal of thermal sciences. Vol. 48, PP. 2
 
[111]  Murugesan, P. Mayilsamy, Y. Suresh, S. and Srinivasan, P. S. S. (2009) “heat transfer and pressure drop characteristic of turbulent flow in tube fitted with trapezoidal-cut twisted insert” international journal of academic research Vol. 1, No. 1, PP. 123-128.
 
[112]  Zhi-min Lin and Wang Bi (2009) “convective heat transfer enhancement in circular tube using twisted tape” J heat transfer Vol. 131, No. 8, PP. 81-91.
 
[113]  Sharma K. V., Syam Sunder L. and Shama P. K. (2009). “estimation of heat transfer coefficient and friction factor in transition flow with low volume concentration of AL2O3 nano-fluid flowing in circular tube with twisted tape” international communication in heat and mass transfer ZVol. 36, No5, PP. 503-507.
 
[114]  Eiamsa-ard, S., Eiamsa-ard, P. and Thianpong C. (2009) “turbulent heat transfer enhancement by counter/ co-swirling flow in tube fitted with twin twisted tape”. experimental thermal and fluid science Vol. 34, No. 1, PP. 53-62.
 
[115]  Seemawute, P. and Eiamsa-ard, S. (2010). “thermodynamics of turbulent flow through around tube by a peripherally-cut twisted tape with alternate axis” international communication in heat and transfer Vol. 37, PP. 652-659.
 
[116]  Syam Sunder L. and Sharma, K. V. (2010). “turbulent heat transfer and friction factor of Al2O3 nanofluid in circular tube with twisted tape insert” international journal of heat and mass transfer Vol. 53, PP. 1409-1416.
 
[117]  Hataa, K. and Masuzakib, S. (2010). “twisted tape induced swirl flow heat transfer and pressure drop in short circular tube under velocities controlled”. Nuclear engineering and design NDE -5980.
 
[118]  Eiamsa-ard, S. (2010). “study on thermal and fluid flow characteristic in turbulent channel flows with multiple twisted tape vortex generators” international journal in heat and mass transfer. Vol. 31 PP. 644-651.
 
[119]  Eiamsa-ard, S. and Pongjet Promvonge (2010). “performance assessment in heat exchanger tube with alternate clockwise and counter clockwise twisted tape insert” international journal of heat and mass transfer Vol. 53, PP.1364-1372.
 
[120]  Cui Yong-zhang and Tian Mao-chang (2010). “threedimension numerical simulation of thermal hydraulic performance of circular tube with edge fold-twisted tape insert” Journal of hydrodynamic Vol. 22, No. 5, PP. 662-670.
 
[121]  Eiamsa-ard, S. and Ponjet Promvonge (2010). “thermal characteristic in round tube fitted with serrated twisted tape”. Applied thermal engineering Vol. 30, PP. 1673-1682.
 
[122]  Saha, S. (2010). “thermodynamic turbulent flow through rectangular and square ducts with axial corrugation roughness and twisted tapes with and without oblique teeth” experimental thermal and fluid science Vol. 34, PP. 744-752.
 
[123]  Eiamsa-ard, S. Wongcharee, K. Eiamsa-ard, P. and Thianpong, C. (2010). “thermohydraulics investigation of turbulent flow through tube equipped with twisted tape consist of center wings and alternate axes”. experimental thermal and fluid science Vol.34, PP. 1151-1161.
 
[124]  Eiamsa-ard, S. Wongcharee, K. Eiamsa-ard, P. and Thianpong, K. (2010) “heat transfer enhancement in a tube using delta-winglet twisted tape insert” Applied thermal engineering Vol. 30, PP. 310-318.
 
[125]  Eiamsa-ard, S. Seemawute, P. and Wongcharee, K. (2010). “influence of peripherally-cut twisted tape insert on heat transfer and thermal performance characteristic in laminar and turbulent tube flow”. experimental thermal and fluid science Vol. 34, PP. 711-719.
 
[126]  Hiejazi V., Akhavan-Behabadi M. A. and Afshari A. (2010). “Experimental investigation of twisted tape insert performance on condensation heat transfer enhancement and pressure drop” Vol. 37, PP. 1376-1387.
 
[127]  Murugesan, P. Mayilsamy, Y. Suresh, S. and Srinivasan, P.S. S. (2011). “heat transfer and pressure drop characteristic in circular tube fitted with and without v-cut twisted tape insert” Int. communications in heat and mass transfer Vol. 38, PP. 329-334.
 
[128]  Jain Guo, Aiwu Fan, Xiaoyu Zhang and Wei Liu (2011) “a numerical study on heat transfer and friction factor characteristic of laminar flow in circular tube fitted with center cleared twisted tape” International journal of thermal science Vol.50, PP. 1263-1270.
 
[129]  Wongcharee, K. and Eiamsa-ard, S. (2011). “enhancement of heat transfer using Cuo/water nanofluid and twisted tape with alternate axis” international communication in heat and mass transfer. Vol. 38, PP. 742-748.
 
[130]  Ferroni, P., Block, R. E., Todreas, N. E. and Bergles, A. E. (2011). “experimental evaluation of pressure drop in round tubes provided with physically separated multiple short length twisted tape” experimental thermal and fluid science.
 
[131]  Hataa K. and Masuzakib S. (2011). “twisted tape induced swirl flow heat transfer and pressure drop in short circular tube under velocities controlled”. Nuclear eng. And design. Vol. 241, PP. 4434-4444.
 
[132]  Yangium W. (2011). “configuration optimization of regular spaced short-length twisted tape in a circular tube to enhance turbulent heat transfer using CFD modeling” Applied thermal eng. Vol. 31, PP. 1141-1149.
 
[133]  Bhuiya M. M. K., Chowdhury M. S., Islam M., Ahmed J. U., Khan M., Sarker M. and Saha M. (2012). “heat transfer performance evaluation for turbulent flow through a tube with twisted wire brush insert” Elsevier, int. communication in heat and mass transfer Vol. 39, PP. 1505-1512.
 
[134]  Halit Bas and Veysl Ozceyhan. (2012). “heat transfer enhancement in a tube with twisted tape insert placed separately from the tube wall” experimental thermal and fluid science. Vol. 41, PP. 51-58.
 
[135]  Veeresh F. and Sarviya. (2012). “experimental investigation of heat transfer enhancement double pipe heat exchanger using twisted tape with wire mesh screen” Int. J. of advance eng. Research and studied PP. 5-9.
 
[136]  Pasaladi M. and Kattempudi R. (2012). “enhancement of heat transfer of laminar flow in a square duct with twisted tape” (IJEST).
 
[137]  Panida S. and Eiasma-arc S. (2012). “visualization of flow and heat transfer in tube with twisted tape consisting of alternate axis” (ICCMS) Vol. 22.
 
[138]  Ibrahim E. Z. (2012). “Heat Transfer Enhancement Inside Elliptic Tube by Means of Rings Inserts” Energy Science and Technology Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 12-19.
 
[139]  Maughal Ahmed, Ibrahim Nouzil, Azzam Shiek, Feraz Mohammed and Thameez (2013). “heat transfer augmentation in concentric tube heat exchanger using twisted tapes” Int. J. of Eng. Research and application ISSN 2248-9622.
 
[140]  Rahul K. and Srinivas P. (2013) “experimental analysis of heat transfer augmentation by using twisted tape of different twisted ratio as flow arrangement inside the tube” Int. J. of modern eng. Research Vol. 3, No. 3, PP. 1371-1323.
 
[141]  Bhuiya M. M. K., Chowdhury M. S. and Islam M. (2013) “performance assessment in a heat exchanger tube fitted with double counter twisted tape insert” Int. communication in heat and mass transfer. PP. 1-9.
 
[142]  Pankaj N. Shrirao, DrRajeshkumar U. Sambhe and Pr adib R. Bodade. (2013). “experimental investigation on turbulent flow heat tranhsfer enhancement in horizontal circular pipe using internal threads of varying depth” IOSR J. of mechanical and civil engineering Vol.5, Issue 3, PP. 23-28.
 
[143]  Bodius Salam, Sumana Biswas, Shuvra Saha and Muhammed Mustafa (2013) “heat transfer enhancement in a tube using rectangular –cut twisted tape insert” 5th int. conference on thermal eng. Vol. 56, PP. 96-103.
 
[144]  Monis Abdulmamon, V. N. Kapatkar (2013). “enhancement of heat transfers with conical hole filament insert in flow through circular tube” international journal of research in mechanical engineering and technology. Vol.3, Issue 2, PP 270-273.
 
[145]  Naga Sarada1 S., P. Ram Reddy2, Gugulothu Ravi (2013) “Experimental Investigations on Augmentation of Turbulent Flow Heat Transfer in A Horizontal Tube Using Square Leaf Inserts” International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering Web Vol. 3, Issue 8, PP. 420-424.
 
[146]  Burse A.K., Yadav R. H. and Sane N. K. (2013). “enhancement of heat transfer in a horizontal circular pipe using twisted tape insert of different twisted ratio” IJAEMVol. 1, PP. 45-52.
 
[147]  Dhamane N., Nalawade D. and Dange M. M. (2014) “performance analysis of wave twisted tape insert of heat transfer in a circular tube” IJTRE Vol. 1, No. 6, ISSN 2347-4718.
 
[148]  Swaminathan S. Periyakaruppan T. and Sivan S. (2014) “experimental studies on effect of bonding the twisted tape eith pins to the inner surface of circular tube” Deprtment of mechanical eng. Nehru institute of technology coimbator, Tamil Nadu, India.
 
[149]  Gawander A. V., Dange M.M. and Nalawade D. B. (2014) “heat transfer enhancement with different square jagged twisted tapes” IJERA ISSN2248-9622.
 
[150]  Eiamsa-ard, S. Pimsarn M. and Thianpong C. (2014). “performance assessment in heat exchanger tube with twisted tape” Department of mechanical eng. Faculty og eng. Mahanakorn university of technology, Bangkok 10530, Thailand.
 
[151]  Heyder M., Reza A., Morshed F., Shabnam J. and Khater A. (2014). “effect of twisted tape tabulator and nanofluid on heat transfer in double pipe heat exchanger” Hindawi publishing corporation J. of eng., Article ID 920970.
 
[152]  Withada Jedsdara Tanchai, Amnart Boomloi. (2014). “effect of twisted ratio on flow structure heat transfer and thermal improvement in a circular with single twisted tape” journal of mathematical and statistic Vol. 10, No. 1 PP80-91.
 
[153]  Matani,A. G., Rafik, S. and Choudhari (2015) “analysis of heat transfer augmentation in tube using triangular wavy tape inserts” international journal of engineering research and general science Vol. 3, Issue. 3 PP 113-119.
 
[154]  Sabber Hossain, Ujjawl Kumar and Kazi Afzalur Rahman (2015). “the enhancement of heat transfer in circular tube with insert by using finite element method “ Science direct procedia engineering 105 PP 81-88.
 
[155]  Mayank Bhola, Mr. Vinod Komar and Dr. Satyendera Singh (2015) “heat transfer enhancement in concentric tube heat exchanger in ANSYS FLUENT “international of innovative science, engineering and technology Vol. 4, Issue 4, PP7-10.
 
[156]  Premkumar M. (2015) "Experimental Study On Heat Transfer Enhancement In A Circular Tube Fitted With ‗U‘-Cut And ‗V‘-Cut Twisted Tape Insert” International Journal on Applications in Mechanical and Production Engineering Vol. 1: Issue 1, pp 19-23.
 
[157]  Aravind Kumar Chaturvedi , ER. Rakesh Kumar (2015) “effect of wire coil inserts in thermal efficiency of solar flat plate liquid collectors” IJESMR Vol. 2, No. 6, pp. 75-83.
 
[158]  Piriyarungrod N., Eiamsa-ard S., Thianpong C., Pimsarn M. and Nanan K. (2015). “heat transfer enhancement by tapered twisted tape inserts” chemical engineering and processing 96 PP62-71.
 
[159]  Avinash Savekar, Dhiraj Jangid, Madhura Gurjar, Vikrant Patil, C. M. Sewatkar (2015) “Analysis of Heat Transfer in Pipe with Twisted Tape Inserts” Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Fluid Flow, Heat and Mass Transfer Canada, No.143, PP.1-8.
 
[160]  Al-Amin, Zunayed Mahmud, Nafis Bin Islam, Lutor Rahman and Mohammed Ali (2015). “heat transfer enhancement using a rotating twisted tape insert”. Journal of modern science and technology Vol. 3, No. 1 p.p 263-271.
 
[161]  Manoj S. Choudhary, Yogesh Tembhurne (2015). “Heat Transfer Enhancement by Twisted Tape Inserts in a Tube Exchanger” IJETMR Vol. 3, PP. 117-122.
 
[162]  Muhammad Khairi Roslim, Suhaimi Hassan and Aklilu Tesfamichael. (2015). “experimental investication on heat transfer enhancement by using porous twisted plate as an insert in a fitted tube” ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences Vol. 10, No. 21 PP. 10164-10168.
 
[163]  Rajesh C. Babu and Santhosh Kumar Gugulothu. (2015). “CFD analysis of heat transfer enhancement by using passive technique heat exchanger “International journal of recent advances in mechanical engineering Vol. 4 No.3 P.P 99-111.
 
[164]  Sudheer V. Kumar and Dr. T. V Raw (2016). “CFD analysis on heat transfer enhancement in horizontal tube by force convection with insert “International journal magazine of engineering technology and research Vol. 3 Issue 2. P.P 1129-1140.
 
[165]  Ranjith and Shaji K (2016) “Numerical analysis on a double pipe heat exchanger with twisted tape induced swirl flow on both side “International conference on engineering trend in engineering, science and technology No. 24, P.P 436-443.
 
[166]  Jyoti V. Patil, Prasal P. Patil and R. Y. Patil (2016) “Experimental investigation of an innovative water heating system with CFD” International Journal of innovative research in science engineering and technology, Vol.5, Issue. 7 P.P 12895-12906.
 
[167]  Pragnesh Kumar Prajrpati, Umang Soni and Ashvin Suthar (2016) “Increase the heat transfer rate of double pipe heat exchanger with quadratic tubular (Baffle) Attached twisted tape insert“. International journal of advance engineering and research development, Vol. 3 Issue. 5 P.P 204-212.
 
[168]  Suvanjun Bhattachryya, Himadri Chattopadhyay and Satyaki, Bandyopadhyay (2016) “Numerical study on heat transfer enhancement through a circular duct filled with a center trimmed – twisted tape”, International journal of heat and technology, Vol. 3 P.P 402-406.
 
[169]  Chakole, M.M, Sali, N.V., Tanekhan, F.S. and Karmwand, S. (2016). “Performance important of tubular heat exchanger by multiple twisted tape inserts and Al2O3, water nanofluid – an experimental study”, International journal of theoretical and applied research in mechanical engineering, Vol.5, No. 1 P.P 1-8.
 
[170]  Nivadita Uzagarra and Premender Bansod. (2016). “Experimental of heat transfer using V-Jagged twisted tape in circular tube “IOSR Journal of mechanical and civil engineering, Vol. 13, Issue. 2, P.P 14-17.
 
[171]  Mr. Krishna S. Borade, Prof. M. Khanwalkar and Prof. V. N. Kapatrar. (2016). “experimental investigation of heat transfer enhancement with different square jagged twisted tape and Cuo/water nanofluid”. Internationl Journal of innovative studies in science and engineering technology, Vol. 2, Issue. 2 P.P 34-39.
 
[172]  Mushan S. G., B.E.Patil, N.K.Sane, D.V.Ghewade Naumov, V. K. and Semashko, N. N. (2017). “Heat Augmentation Using Non-metallic Insert in Forced Convection” IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering PP. 81-88.
 
[173]  D. R. Hase, N. K. Sane, and D. V. Ghewade. (2017). “Heat augmentation with using non-matallic flow divider type insert in force convection” 6th National conference RDME P.P 62-67.
 
[174]  K. Syed Jafar and B. Sivaraman (2017) “Performance characteristics of parabolic solar collecter water heater system filled with nail twisted tape absorber” Journal of engineering science and technology, Vol. 12, No. 3 P.P 608-621.
 
[175]  V. Trupati Rao, A. Rupesh Voukata RAmana and Dr. T. Dharma Rajn. (2017). “Augmentation heat transfer in circular tube using conical ring and twisted tape insert” IJSRET Vol.6, Issue 1 P.P 45-52.
 
[176]  Prof. Rahul M. Dahekar, Mr. Moneyiosh Jindey, Mr. Paresh Sathawene and Mr. Akash Atram (2017) “An experimental investigation of performance of different twiste tape inserts on heat augmentation “ IJARIIE Vol. 3 Issue. 3 P.P 3003-3009.
 
[177]  Ajit R. Shinde, Yogesh J. Bhalerao and Nilesh B. Totla (2017) “Thermal performance of serrated plate inserts in circular tube” SARC International conference 26th march P.P 7-12.
 
[178]  A. H. Dhumal, G. M. Kerkal and K. T. Pawale (2017) “heat transfer enhancement for tube in tube heat exchanger using twisted tape inserts “ IJAERS Vol. 4, Issue. 5 P.P 89-92.
 
[179]  W. Sodsri, S.Tamna, E. Thianpong and P.Promvong (2017) “Numerical thermal study in heat exchanger tube with inclined elliptic ring “7th international conference on environment and industrial innovation.
 
Manuscript template