Football Cooperative, a Community Based Physical Activity Social Initiative for Men: Protocol Paper for a Pragmatic Feasibility Trial

Carroll P.^1, , Daly S.¹, Egan T.², Harrison M.¹, Richardson N.³, Finnegan L.⁴, McGrath A.¹ and Krustrup P.^{5, 6}

¹Centre for Health Behaviour Research, South East Technological University, Ireland

²Department of Accountancy and Economics, South East Technological University, Ireland

³National Centre for Men’s Health, South East Technological University, Ireland

⁴Football Research Group, South East Technological University, Ireland

⁵Department of Sports Science and Clinical Biomechanics, Sport and Health Sciences Cluster (SHSC), Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Denmark, Odense, Denmark

⁶Danish Institute for Advanced Study (DIAS), University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark

Cite this paper:
Carroll P., Daly S., Egan T., Harrison M., Richardson N., Finnegan L., McGrath A. and Krustrup P.. Football Cooperative, a Community Based Physical Activity Social Initiative for Men: Protocol Paper for a Pragmatic Feasibility Trial. Journal of Physical Activity Research. 2023; 8(1):16-26. doi: 10.12691/jpar-8-1-4

Abstract

The case for a focus on men’s health is unequivocal; men, and poorer men in particular, continue to experience an excess burden of ill-health, mortality and premature death and both national and European policy has called for gender competent service provision to address this fundamental inequality in health. While lessons have been learned in recent years with respect to developing gender competency in service provision, there is value in considering how they can be applied to other settings, other sub populations of men and other types of initiatives (beyond the limitations of a structured programme). Such initiatives may appeal beyond the ‘worried well’ to more ‘hard to reach’ (HTR) groups of men who are most in need of such initiatives thereby ensuring that all men are reached in health promotion and preventative efforts. Football Cooperative (FC) is uniquely Irish and is a community-based initiative that provides social ‘pick up football’ games for men aimed at improving their overall health and wellbeing. In a series of papers, we propose to evaluate FC, however, we are not proposing to create something to be trialed but rather to use research to assess the social return on investment (SROI) and health and economic impact of a ‘real world’ organic initiative so that the feasibility for scale up can be determined. If feasible, plans will be put in place to upscale the FC initiative to improve reach (population and geographical access) and equitable access to the games and the games benefits. The purpose of this paper is to detail the protocols used in the evaluation of the FC initiative and by doing so, others engaged in translational research may be supported to ensure that efficacious initiatives translate into practice for the benefit of population health.

Keywords:
protocol men’s health recreational football community based social return on investment

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References:

[1]	World Health Organisation European Regional Obesity Report 2022. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe; 2022. Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO. 2022.
[2]	Baker, P., White, A., and Morgan, R. Men's health: COVID-19 pandemic highlights need for overdue policy action. Lancet; 395(10241). 1886-8. June 2020.
[3]	Richardson, N., and Smith, J.A., Robertson, S., Baker, P. Global men’s health policy. In: Griffith, D.M., Bruce, M.A., Thorpe, R.J., eds. Men’s health equity: a handbook. New York: Routledge, 2019.
[4]	World Health Organisation Regional Office for Europe. Strategy on the Health and Well-being of men in the WHO European Region. 2018. Available at: https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/394894/MHR_strategy_Eng_online.pdf.
[5]	Mursa, R., Patterson, C. and Halcomb, E. Men's help-seeking and engagement with general practice: An integrative review. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 78. 1938-1953. Apr 2022.
[6]	Van Doorn, D., Richardson, N., Meredith, D., Blake, C., and McNamara, J. Study protocol: Evaluation of the ‘real-world’ Farmers Have Hearts –Cardiovascular Health Program. Preventive Medicine, Reports 30(29). 102010. Dec 2022.
[7]	Kelly, L., Harrison, M., Richardson, N., Carroll, P., Robertson, S., Keohane, A., and Donohoe, A. The impact of a gender-specific physical activity intervention on the fitness and fatness profile of men in Ireland. European Journal of Public Health, 29(6). 1154-1160. Dec 2019.
[8]	McGrath, A., Murphy, N., Egan, T., and Richardson, N. Sheds for life: health and wellbeing outcomes of a tailored community-based health promotion initiative for men's sheds in Ireland. Biomedical Central Public Health, 22(1). 1590. Aug 2022.
[9]	Hunt, K., Wyke, S., Gray, C.M., Anderson, A.S., Brady, A., Bunn, C., Donnan, P.T., Fenwick, E., Grieve, E., Leishman, J., Miller, E., Mutrie, N., Rauchhau, P., White, A., and Treweek, S. A gender-sensitised weight loss and healthy living programme for overweight and obese men delivered by Scottish Premier League football clubs (FFIT): a pragmatic randomised controlled trial. Lancet, 383. 1211-21. Jan 2014.
[10]	Wyke, S., Bunn, C., Andersen, E., Silva, M.N., van Nassau, F., McSkimming, P., Kolovos, S., Gill, J.M.R., Gray, C.M., Hunt, K., et al. The effect of a programme to improve men’s sedentary time and physical activity: The European Fans in Training (EuroFIT) randomised controlled trial. PLoS Medicine, 16. e1002736. Feb 2019.
[11]	Kwasnicka, D., Ntoumanis, N., Hunt, K., Gray, C.M., Newton, R.U., Gucciardi, D.F., Thøgersen-Ntoumani, C., Olson, J.L., McVeigh, J., Kerr, D.A., Wyke, S., Morgan, P.J., Robinson, S., Makate, M., and Quested, E. A gender-sensitised weight-loss and healthy living program for men with overweight and obesity in Australian Football League settings (Aussie-FIT): A pilot randomised controlled trial. PLoS Medicine, 6; 17(8). e1003136. Aug 2020.
[12]	Maddison, R., Hargreaves, E.A., Wyke, S., Gray, C.M., Hunt, K., Heke, J.I., Kara, S., Ni Mhurchu, C., Jull, A., Jiang, Y., et al. Rugby Fans in Training New Zealand (RUFIT-NZ): A pilot randomized controlled trial of a healthy lifestyle program for overweight men delivered through professional rugby clubs in New Zealand. Biomedical Central Public Health, 19. 166. Feb 2019.
[13]	Robertson, C., Archibald, D., Avenell, A., Douglas, F., Hoddinott, P., van Teijlingen, E. et al. Systematic reviews and integrated report on the quantitative, qualitative and eco-nomic evidence base for the management of obesity in men. Health Technological Assess, 18. 1-424. May 2014.
[14]	Carroll, P., Kirwan, L., and Lambe, B. Engaging ‘hard to reach’ men in community based health promotion. International Journal of Health Promotion and Education, 52. 120-130. May 2014.
[15]	Robertson, L. M., Douglas, F., Ludbrook, A., Reid, G. and van Teijlingen, E. What works with men? A systematic review of health promoting interventions targeting men. Biomedical Central Health Services Research, 3(8). 141. July 2008.
[16]	Milligan, C., Neary, D., Payne, S., Hanratty, B., Irwin, P., and Dowrick, C. Older men and social activity: a scoping review of Men's Sheds and other gendered interventions. Ageing and Society, 36(5). 895-923. January 2016.
[17]	McGrath, A., Murphy, N. and Richardson, N. ‘Sheds for Life’: delivering a gender-transformative approach to health promotion in Men’s Sheds. Health Promotion International, 37(6). daac150. Dec 2022.
[18]	Sagar-Ouriaghli, I., Godfrey, E., Bridge, L., Meade, L., and Brown, J. S. L. Improving Mental Health Service Utilization Among Men: A Systematic Review and Synthesis of Behaviour Change Techniques Within Interventions Targeting Help-Seeking. American Journal of Men's Health, 13(3). May-June 2019.
[19]	Sharp, P., Bottorff, J. L., Rice, S., Oliffe, J. L., Schulenkorf, N., Impellizzeri, F., and Caperchione, C. M. “People say men don't talk, well that's bullshit”: A focus group study exploring challenges and opportunities for men's mental health promotion. PloS One, 17(1). e0261997. Jan 2022.
[20]	Oliffe, J.L., Bottorff, J.L., McKenzie, M.M., Hislop, T.G., Gerbrandt, J. S. and Oglov, V. (2011) Prostate cancer support groups, health literacy and consumerism: Are community-based volunteers re-defining older men’s health? Health, 15. 555-570. Nov 2011.
[21]	Grace, B., Richardson, N., and Carroll, P. “…if you’re not part of the institution you fall by the wayside”: Service provider’s perspectives on moving young men from disconnection and isolation to connection and belonging. American Journal of Men’s Health, 12(2). 252-264. Mar 2018.
[22]	Lefkowick, M, Richardson, N., Brennen, L., Lambe, B., and Carroll P. A process evaluation of a Training of Trainers (TOT) model of health training in Ireland. Health Promotion International, 33(1). 60-70. Feb 2018.
[23]	Pringle, A., Hargreaves, J., Lozano, L., McKenna J. and Zwolinsky S. Assessing the impact of football-based health improvement programmes: stay onside, avoid own goals and score with the evaluation!, Soccer & Society, 15(6). 970-987. May 2014.
[24]	Bangsbo, J., Hansen, P.R., Dvorak, J., and Krustrup, P. Recreational football for disease prevention and treatment in untrained men: a narrative review examining cardiovascular health, lipid profile, body composition, muscle strength and functional capacity. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 49(9). 568-76. May 2015.
[25]	Krustrup P, Williams CA, Mohr M, Hansen PR, Helge EW, Elbe AM, de Sousa M, Dvorak J, Junge A, Hammami A, Holtermann A, et al. The “Football is Medicine” platform-scientific evidence, large-scale implementation of evidence-based concepts and future perspectives. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, Suppl 1. 3-7. Aug 2018.
[26]	Krustrup, P., Aagaard, P., Nybo, L., Petersen, J., Mohr, M. and Bangsbo, J. Recreational football as a health promoting activity: a topical review. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 20. 1-13. April 2010.
[27]	Jakobsen, M.D., Sundstrup, E., Krustrup, P., and Aagaard P. (2011). The effect of recreational soccer training and running on postural balance in untrained men. European Journal of Applied Physiology 111. 521-530. Mar 2011.
[28]	Andersen, T.R., Schmidt, J.F., Thomassen, M., et al. A preliminary study: effects of football training on glucose control, body composition, and performance in men with type 2 diabetes. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 24(Suppl 1). 43-56. Aug 2014.
[29]	Milanović, Z., Pantelić, S., Čović, N., Sporiš, G., Mohr. M. and Krustrup, P. Broad-spectrum physical fitness benefits of recreational football: a systematic review and meta-analysis. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 53(15). 926-939. Aug 2019.
[30]	Sarmento, H., Clemente, F.M., Marques, A., Milanovic, Z., Harper, L.D. and Figueiredo, A. Recreational football is medicine against non-communicable diseases: A systematic review. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 30 (4). 618-637. Apr 2020.
[31]	Milanović, Z., Pantelić, S., Čović, N., Sporiš, G. and Krustrup, P. Is Recreational soccer effective for improving VO2max? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Medicine, 45(9). 1339-1353. Sept 2015.
[32]	Elbe, A.M., Strahler, K., Krustrup, P., Wikman, J., and Stelter, R. Experiencing flow in different types of physical activity intervention programs: three randomized studies. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 20 Suppl 1. 111-7. Apr 2020.
[33]	Ottesen, L., Jeppesen, R.S., and Krustrup B.R. The development of social capital through football and running: studying an intervention program for inactive women. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sport, 20 Suppl 1. 118-31. Apr 2010.
[34]	White, A., and Witty, K. Men’s under-use of health services—Finding alternative approaches. Journal of Men’s Health, 6(2), 95-97. May 2009.
[35]	Spandler, H. and McKeown, M. A Critical Exploration of Using Football in Health and Welfare Programs: Gender, Masculinities, and Social Relations. Journal of Sport and Social Issues, 36(4). 387-409. Oct 2012.
[36]	Robertson, S. Understanding men and health: Masculinities, identity and well-being. Buckingham, UK: Open University Press. 2007.
[37]	Robertson, S. “If I let a goal in, I’ll get beat up”: Contradictions in masculinity, sport and health. Health Education Research, 18(6). 706-716. Dec 2003.
[38]	Oliffe, J. L., Rossnagel, E., Bottorff, J. L., Chambers, S. K., Caperchione, C., and Rice, S. M. Community-based men's health promotion programs: eight lessons learnt and their caveats. Health Promotion International, 35(5). 1230-1240. Oct 2020.
[39]	Koorts, H., Eakin, E., Estabrooks, P., Timperio, A., Salmon, J., and Bauman, A. Implementation and scale up of population physical activity interventions for clinical and community settings: the PRACTIS guide. International Journal of Behavioural Nutrition & Physical Activity, 15(1). 51. June 2018.
[40]	Glasgow, R.E., Lichtenstein, E., and Marcus, A.C. Why don’t we see more translation of health promotion research to practice? Rethinking the efficacy-to- effectiveness transition. American Journal of Public Health, 93. 1261-67. Aug 2003.
[41]	Social Value UK and Social Value International. The Principles of Social Value, and why they are important for accountability and maximising social value. 2015. Available at: https://socialvalueuk.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Social-Value-Principles-and-Accountability-1.pdf.
[42]	Carroll, P., Harrison, M., Richardson, N., Robertson, S., Keohane, A., Kelly, L., and Donohoe, A. Evaluation of a Gender-Sensitive Physical Activity Programme for Inactive Men in Ireland: Protocol Paper for a Pragmatic Controlled Trial. Journal of Physical Activity Research, 3(1). 20-27. Mar 2018.
[43]	United Nations Development Group. Theory of Change. UNDAF Companion Guidance. Available at: Microsoft Word - UNDG-UNDAF-Companion-Pieces-7-Theory-of-Change.docx Retrieved Mar 9th 2023.
[44]	Fennell, C., Eremus, T., Puyana, M.G., and Sañudo, B. The Importance of Physical Activity to Augment Mood during COVID-19 Lockdown. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2022; 19(3). 1270. Jan 2022.
[45]	Harris, A.D., McGregor, J.C., Perencevich, E.N., Furuno, J.P., Zhu, J., Peterson, D.E., and Finkelstein, J. The use and interpretation of quasi-experimental studies in medical informatics. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 13(1). 16-23. Jan – Feb 2006.
[46]	Grgic, J., Oppici, L., Mikulic, P., Bangsbo, J., Krustrup, P., and Pedisic, Z. Test-Retest Reliability of the Yo-Yo Test: A Systematic Review. Sports Medicine, 49(10). 1547-1557. Oct 2019.
[47]	Schmitz, B., Pfeifer, C., Kreitz, K., Borowski, M., Faldum, A., and Brand, S.M.. The Yo-Yo Intermittent Tests: A Systematic Review and Structured Compendium of Test Results. Frontiers in Physiology, 5(9). 870. July 2018.
[48]	Snyder, E., Cai, B., DeMuro, C., Morrison, M.F., and Ball, W. A New Single-Item Sleep Quality Scale: Results of Psychometric Evaluation in Patients With Chronic Primary Insomnia and Depression. Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine, 14(11). 1849-1857. Nov 2018.
[49]	Rosenberg, M. Conceiving the Self. New York: Basic Books. 1979.
[50]	Russell, D.W. UCLA Loneliness Scale (Version 3): Reliability, validity, and factor structure. Journal of Personality Assessment, 66(1). 20-40. Feb 1996.
[51]	Wood, R. (2018), “All About The Yo-Yo Intermittent Recovery Test Level 1” The Complete Guide to the Yo-Yo Test. Available at: https://www.theyoyotest.com/yyir1.htm. Retrieved Mar 3rd 2023.
[52]	Callow, D.D., Arnold-Nedimala, N.A., Jordan, L.S., Pena, G.S., Won, J., Woodard, J.L., and Smith, J.C. The mental health benefits of physical activity in older adults survive the COVID-19 pandemic. The American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 28(10). 1046-1057. Oct 2020.
[53]	Department of Health and Children (Prepared by; Richardson, N. and Carroll, P.). National Men’s Health Policy 2008-2013. Working with men in Ireland to achieve optimum health and wellbeing. Dublin: Department of Health. 2009. Available at: http://www.dohc.ie/publications/pdf/.
[54]	Hammersley, C., Meredith, D., Richardson, N., Carroll, P., and McNamara, J. (2022). Mental health, societal expectations and changes to the governance of farming: Reshaping what it means to be a ‘good farmer’ Sociologia Ruralis. Oct 2022.
[55]	Health Services Executive (Prepared by: Richardson, N. and Carroll, P.). National Men’s Health Action Plan. Healthy Ireland - Men. HI-M 2017-2021. Working with men in Ireland to achieve optimum health and wellbeing. Dublin: Health Services Executive. 2017. Available at: https://www.mhfi.org/HI-M.pdf.
[56]	Carroll, P., Richardson, N., and Grace B. Connecting with Young Men: The Impact of Training in Ireland. International Journal of Men’s Social and Community Health, 3(1). e24-e35. May 2020.
[57]	Robertson, S. Carroll, P., Donohoe, A., Richardson, N., Keohane, A., Kelly, L., and Harrison, M. “The environment was Like They Were in The Pub but with no alcohol” – a Process evaluation of engagement and sustainability in ‘Men on the Move’ an Irish community based physical activity intervention. International Journal of Men’s Social and Community Health, 1(1). e1-e14. Oct 2018.
[58]	Schmitz, B., Pfeifer, C., Krietz, K., Borowski, M., Faldum, A. and Brand, S.M. The YoY o Intermittent Tests: A systematic review and structured compendium of results. Frontiers in Physiology, 9(870). July 2018.
[59]	Welsby, D., Nguyen, B., O’Hara, B.J., Innes-Hughes, C., Bauman, A., and Hardy, L.L. Process evaluation of an up-scaled community-based child obesity treatment program: NSW Go4Fun. Biomedical Central Public Health, 14. 140. Feb 2014.
[60]	Hawe, P. (2015). Lessons from Complex Interventions to Improve Health. Annual Review of Public Health, 36(1). 307-323. Mar 2015.
[61]	Carson, C.C. Why men’s health? Postgraduate Medicine, 133(S4). 1-3. June 2020.
[62]	Pan American Health Organisation. Editorial: Addressing masculinities and mens health to advance universal health. Jan 2019. Available at: Editorial: Addressing masculinity and men’s health to advance universal health - PAHO/WHO | Pan American Health Organization.