Barriers Contributing to Policy Deviation: A Mixed Methods Study of Policymakers and Frontline Nurses

John Newans¹ and Nazlee Siddiqui^2,

¹Risk and Policy Unit, South Western Sydney Local Health District, Sydney, Australia

²Australian Institute of Health Services Management, Tasmanian School of Business & Economics, Sydney, Australia

Cite this paper:
John Newans and Nazlee Siddiqui. Barriers Contributing to Policy Deviation: A Mixed Methods Study of Policymakers and Frontline Nurses. American Journal of Nursing Research. 2021; 9(5):164-170. doi: 10.12691/ajnr-9-5-2

Abstract

Deviation from the policy at the point of care is frequently studied as a balancing act of health professionals, resulting in a lesser focus on barriers leading to such deviation. This study investigated practices of policy application or deviation with two aims. One, to assess if the frontline nursing staff is applying or deviating from the policy. Two, to understand the barriers that lead to policy deviation from the perspectives of policymakers and frontline staff. An explanatory sequential mixed methods design was applied, with a quantitative survey first (n=50) and then two qualitative focus group discussions. Data was collected in 2018 within a Local Health District (LHD) in New South Wales, Australia. Most respondents (96%) rated policy application to be the usual practice at work. Despite that, survey respondents (54%) agreed to have discretionally acted against policy requirements. Frontline nurses deviated from policy when they perceived a lack of functional merit. Examples of barriers that contributed to deviation from policy are unstructured policy review, inadequate support for policy writing and communication challenges during policy implementation. These barriers were jeopardizing appropriate policy development and implementation and often negatively influenced the functional merit of policy. A few known strategies, such as appointing policy champions and promoting policy messages through a combination of channels, should be considered to mitigate the identified barriers. Future studies can explore effective ways to manage policy deviation rather than relying on street-level bureaucracy.

Keywords:
policy deviation policymakers frontline nursing staff practice policy at point of care barriers

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

References:

[1]	Westbrook JI, R.M., Woods A, et al. , Errors in the administration of intravenous medications in hospital and the role of correct procedures and nurse experience. BMJ Quality & Safety, 2011. 20 (1027).
[2]	Mula CT, H.N.a.M.L., An exploration of workarounds and their perceived impact on antibiotic stewardship in the adult medical wards of a referral hospital in Malawi: a qualitative study. BMC Health Serv Res, 2019. 19: p. 64-64.
[3]	Blijleven, V., et al., Workarounds emerging from electronic health record system usage: Consequences for patient safety, effectiveness of care, and efficiency of care. JMIR Hum Factors, 2017. 4(4): p. e27.
[4]	Johannessen, L.E.F., Workplace assimilation and professional jurisdiction: How nurses learn to blur the nursing-medical boundary. Social science & medicine (1982), 2018. 201: p. 51-58.
[5]	Borry, E.L. and A.C. Henderson, Patients, Protocols, and Prosocial Behavior: Rule Breaking in Frontline Health Care. American Review of Public Administration, 2019. 00(0): p. 1-17.
[6]	O'Neil, S., Speroni, K. G., Dugan, L., & Daniel, M. G., A 2-tier Study of Direct Care Providers Assessing the Effectiveness of the Red Rule Education Project and Precipitating Factors Surrounding Red Rule Violations. Quality Management in Healthcare, 2010. 19(3).
[7]	Hoyle, L., ‘I mean, obviously you're using your discretion’: Nurses Use of Discretion in Policy Implementation. Social policy and society: a journal of the Social Policy Association, 2014. 13(02): p. 189-202.
[8]	Hughes, A. and L. Condon, Street-level bureaucracy and policy implementation in community public health nursing: a qualitative study of the experiences of student and novice health visitors. Primary Health Care Research & Development, 2016. 17(6): p. 586-598.
[9]	Vos J, F.B., Chumbley G, et al., Nurses as a source of system-level resilience: Secondary analysis of qualitative data from a study of intravenous infusion safety in English hospitals. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 2020. 102: p. 103468.
[10]	Kenyon, M., What are Policies and Procedures?’ Power DMS; viewed 15 January 2021, https://www.powerdms.com/blog/what-are-policies-and-procedures/. 2018, Power DMS.
[11]	Debono, D.S., Nurses’ workarounds in acute healthcare settings: a scoping review. BMC health services research, 2013. 13(1).
[12]	Nunes, J. and G. Lotta, Discretion, power and the reproduction of inequality in health policy implementation: Practices, discursive styles and classifications of Brazil's community health workers. Social Science & Medicine, 2019. 242.
[13]	Hoyle, L., Nurses' perception of senior managers at the front line: people working with clipboards. Journal of advanced nursing, 2014. 70(11): p. 2528-2538.
[14]	Catallo, C., K. Spalding, and R. Haghiri-Vijeh, Nursing professional organizations: What are they doing to engage nurses in health policy? SAGE Open, 2014. 4(4).
[15]	Brunetto, Y., Xerri, M & Farr-Wharton, B., Comparing the role of personal and organisational support on the innovative behaviour of frontline healthcare workers in Australia and the United States. Australian Journal of Public Administration, 2020. 79(3): p. 279-297.
[16]	Rohweder, C.L., et al., Bridging Research, Practice, and Policy: The “evidence Academy” Conference Model. Journal of Public Health Management and Practice, 2016. 22(2): p. 200-203.
[17]	Howlett, M., Moving policy implementation theory forward: A multiple streams/critical juncture approach. Public Policy and Administration, 2019. 34(4): p. 405-430.
[18]	Howlett, M., A. McConnell, and A. Perl, Moving policy theory forward: connecting multiple stream and advocacy coalition frameworks to policy cycle models of analysis. Australian Journal of Public Administration, 2017. 76(1): p. 65-79.
[19]	NSW Health, NSW Health Policy Directives and Other Policy Documents, N. Health, Editor. 2016.
[20]	NSW Ministry of Health, IB2016_013 NSW Hospital Peer Groups 2016. Information bulletin. 2016, NSW Ministry of Health: North Sydney, NSW, Australia.
[21]	Vanderbilt University. Redcap. 2006 [cited 2021 27 January]; Available from: https://projectredcap.org.
[22]	Holland, P.J., Tham, T. L. & Gill, F. J., What nurses and midwives want: Findings from the national survey on workplace climate and well-being. International Journal of Nursing Practice, 2018.
[23]	Smith, G.P.W., T. M., You can lead a horse to water... what Self-Determination Theory can contribute to our understanding of clinical policy implementation. Journal of Health Services Research & Policy, 2017. 22(1): p. 37-44.
[24]	Brownson, R.C., Eyler, A. A., Harris, J. K., Moore, J. B., & Tabak, R.G., Getting the Word out: New Approaches for Disseminating Public Health Science. Journal of Public Health Management and Practice, 2018. 24(2): p. 102-111.
[25]	Havinga, J., Dekker, S. and Rae, A., Everyday work investigations for safety. Theoretical Issues in Ergonomics Science, 2018. 19(2): p. 213-228.
[26]	Byrne, M.D., Nurse Engagement in Health Care Information Technology Policy. Journal of PeriAnesthesia Nursing, 2016. 31(1): p. 99-102.
[27]	Jansson, B.S., et al., Validation of the Policy Advocacy Engagement Scale for frontline healthcare professionals. Nursing Ethics, 2015. 24(3): p. 362-375.
[28]	Petriwskyj, A., A. Gibson, and G. Webby, Staff members' negotiation of power in client engagement: Analysis of practice within an Australian aged care service. Journal of Aging Studies, 2015. 33: p. 37-46.
[29]	Taylor, M.R.S., Impact of Advocacy Initiatives on Nurses' Motivation to Sustain Momentum in Public Policy Advocacy. Journal of Professional Nursing, 2016. 32(3): p. 235-245.
[30]	Bullock, H.L.L., J. N., Understanding the supports needed for policy implementation: a comparative analysis of the placement of intermediaries across three mental health systems. Health Research Policy and Systems, 2019. 17(82).
[31]	O'Connor, S., Using social media to engage nurses in health policy development. Journal of Nursing Management, 2017. 25(8): p. 632-639.